Sociocultural critique on “interpreting the origin of Gender Inequality” Applied Within the Field of Archaeology
We, as anthropologists, have a specific role in studying the human race and accurately record our findings. However, that is not always the case. Sometimes individuals get the story wrong, creating a chain reaction of a web of false narratives.
Recording your observations and findings doesn’t seem like it is that difficult. Still, as we can see through the article “interpreting the origin of Gender Inequality” by Leacock, it has been a recurring issue among many ethnographers in various societies. And if there is an issue within one subfield… is there in others? And should we look for them? Well, the answer is YES! And I’ll share an example and compare it to Leacock’s Article.
This excerpt reminded me of a research topic I choose to tackle last year called the “Excavation of Masculinity” within archeological interpretations. I analyzed a case where an anthropologist didn’t exhaust their resources, stopping once they got what they wanted like the ethnographers within Leacok’s article.
Dr. Hjalmar Stlope was a Swedish anthropologist who conducted several excavations within the mid to late 1800s. However, the Bjorko (BJ.581 unit) gravesite, in particular, didn’t get the proper attention it deserved. This site was on the first know Viking age settlement, a popular trading hub within the Viking circles. So when a gravesite, BJ.581, was discovered containing a fully clothed, strategically placed skeleton alongside a plethora of weapons, material culture, and a complete set of gaming pieces. The gaming pieces indicated to the archeologist that this was the remains of a high-ranking Viking officer who was efficient at tactics and strategies, thus a great warrior. So with all of this in mind, with the addition of this site being one of the most elaborate on the island, Stlope assumed that the gender of the individual had to be male because he projected the gender norms of his time on this past civilization. So for 128 years, the gender of arguably the most decorated Viking warrior was classified as a man when it was later found to be a Female Viking Warrior. So Stlope could have utilized osteology, the study of bone structure and functions used since 1796. This could have clearly shown that her pelvis was more prominent and wider subpubic angle, ventral arc, and inlet. But he chose not to dig further metaphorically, and we will never know precisely why.
So this now brings me back to Leacock’s article where she analyzed the works of past ethnographers and debunked their take on women’s roles within society. Many tried to give the notion with the overarching sense that women are universally subordinate or inferior to men. So this was honestly a great example of correcting the wrongs of our past and rewriting history to include the proper narratives of those oppressed. This completely aligns with her background of being a feminist and a Marxist, which is pretty evident through her approach and immediately calls out Levi-Strauss for playing a role in gender inequality that we see today, depicting women as being “historical commodities.” She later stated that the big issue within the recording of ethnographic studies was that they didn’t always study cultural history outside of whatever they are specifically looking for. And as soon as they find the answer to their question, they start writing their paper, similarly to what we saw within the field of archaeology with slope.
She also goes on to explain that gender inequality is actually attributed to capitalism, once again agreeing with Marx. She explained that primitive communism and how societies were originally more communal and helpful to each other through using many examples. One being the Native Americans, where women had more of a role within society through production and the economy. And it wasn’t until they were exploited, after colonization and the introduction of capitalism, that there was an issue with misinterpretation.
So as a field, we just have to continue to go rewrite the wrongs of the past and do our best and exhaust every resource to properly present the very unique culture and materials entrusted to us to share with outsiders of their groups. So if we can see evidence of archaeologists misgendering a Viking warrior as a male when it is in fact, female, we should leave no stone unturned until even the past and current gender inequalities are resolved and thanks to individuals like Leacocks with her forward approach there is hope!
-Christianestrada99
Thanks for bringing in the archaeological perspective!
ReplyDelete