Critique of Joking Relations
BY: LISETTE VICTORIA SAN PEDRO
Radcliffe-Brown distinguishes the idea of joking
relationships by describing “a relation between two persons in which one is …
permitted to tease or make fun of the other, who in turn is required to take no
offence (Brown 195). He clarifies two types of relationships symmetrical and asymmetrical.
A symmetrical relationship permits for both parties to tease each other, while asymmetrical
relationships allow for one person to make jokes at the expense of the other
and receive no rebuttal. Also, types of teasing vary from society and can
encompass both verbal and physical expressions. The joking relationship is an
uncanny combination of friendliness and antagonism that may be understood as
hostility in certain contexts. For example, a common record is within Dogon men,
he may tease his wife’s sisters and daughters, or anyone in or around her kin
group that is younger than her. Additionally, joking with the wife’s brothers
and sister “is usually associated with a custom requiring extreme respect”, while
“partial or complete avoidance, between a son-in-law and his wife’s parents” is
meant to represent gratitude for his marital blessing (196). More so, Radcliffe-Brown’s
theory surrounding this notion is heavily influenced by structural-functionalism
by how he reduces the reasoning of this phenomenon in binaries. For example, as
the husband departs from his social structure and enters as an outside into his
wife’s family, his social disjunction may raise conflict between their interests
and thus be thwarted by light-hearted banter. This disjunction counters his conjunction,
which was once found in his social and kin groups. Additionally, the show of hostility
and constant disrespect is an expression of one’s social disjunction, yet it constitutes
an alliance that “organiz[es] a definite and stable system of social behavior
in which conjunctive and disjunctive components” are maintained (200). In other
words, Radcliffe-Brown believes joking relationships work to dismantle any
possible power struggles, frustration from a lack of compatibility, and anxieties
associated with joining a new social group. These ideas are indicative of structural-functionalist’s
reduction of individual agency and over assumptions that behaviors serve a role
for social cohesion.
Radcliffe-Brown fails to clarify distinct meanings of ‘joking’
relations, leading to behavioral assumptions, without considering the role of
the individual. First, Radcliffe-Brown’s research is centered in social groups
where one’s social relations are well determined. This means that most jokes
are well calculated and there are obvious social rules for who and how you can disrespect
people older, richer, and more powerful than you. In this case, Radcliffe-Brown
mentions how the Dogon men avoid the chastising of mother in laws because his greatest
gift, his wife, is a direct product of her, creating a so called ‘best friend’
between the two. However, in situations where one’s social ranking is equal or
undetermined, jokes are made in order to form such bonds and have no obligation
to follow cultural norms of respect. By failing to consider this, Radcliffe-Brown
grossly underestimates the function of jokes in order to create social conjunction.
He presumes that jokes maintain harmony within a transition from social
conjunction to disjunction, hence hostility is expected. Yet, joking solely to
form friendships carries out distinct characteristics of those detailed by Radcliffe-Brown.
Also, his modes of alliances, which include though intermarriage, by exchange
of goods and services, by blood brotherhood, or by the joking relationship,
indicates that joking to form conjunction was barely considered. As many other
structural and functionalist ideas, his work is highly reductive and his concentration
to one side of the binary neglects important functions for social creation and maintenance.
LV, I think you did a phenomenal job of explaining and describing Radcliffe-Browne’s ideas of Joking Relationships and you brought up a couple points that I didn’t pick-up on or think about when I was first reading it myself. Your examples of different joking relationships made me think about my parents and their relationships, specifically my father and his mother-in-law and father-in-law or my grandparents and how these two relationships differ. One of these relationships, my dad and my grandma have an asymmetrical joking relationship as she jokes with him as loving and caring actions, but he does not joke around with her out of respect because she is the mother of his wife and she has helped him become part of a larger family. However, the relationship between my father and my grandfather is a symmetrical joking relationship, as they initially were very cold to each other early in my parent’s courtship but over time they have come to share a strong bond and I believe the constant joking around is a way to better their relationship in terms of easing their anxiety when speaking to one another as well as an unsaid sign that they have respect and care for one another. I also completely agree with your statement commenting on Radcliffe-Brown’s underestimation on the power of joking relationships in forming social conjunction. As you state in the second paragraph of your post, Radcliffe-Brown’s sample is in situations where social relations are well-determined which means that everyone in the society knows their role, what to say, and when to say it, however, in situations when they are not defined, an area that he had not researched as in-depth there are definitely areas where these joking relationships allow for social conjunction among relationships that were at one time harsh.
ReplyDelete