RESPONSE TO JARRETT'S "A CRITIQUE OF "WHAT IS A SOCIAL FACT?""

Hi Jarrett. Firstly, I would say that I really enjoyed reading your critique of "What is a Social Fact?" by Émile Durkheim. Your critique is not only clear on sorting out the main concept of Durkheim, but it is also very creative and thoughtful, especially at the part where you make a comparison between Sigmund Freud saying that human enculturation takes place from parents to children and Durkheim's idea of early childhood development and education. I thought about almost the same thing when I was reading this article, but I also realized that there is a big conceptual and theoretical difference underlying the words of Freud and Durkheim, that is while Durkheim claims that society is cohesive and should be viewed as a whole, Sigmund argued that what is happening is because human beings are essentially the same (his psychic unity theory). It is interesting to see how two almost opposite theories - society’s coercive power on individuals and the psychic unity - can lead to similar ideas, isn’t it?


I definitely agree with the idea that at the childhood stage of a person, it is the parents that could most influence them through family education, teaching them how to act, speak, and function properly within the society. At one’s early age, almost all of his or her perception comes from what their parents have. However, as one grows older, the influence from society, from school, from other people around an individual might exceed or even replace parental education. In either case, it is indeed a fact that the collective consciousness does exist in society and every one of us is influenced by it. One person that I am thinking of who might be against this is the German philosopher Nietzsche, who proposed the idea of "overman". An overman, in his concept, is the one who is willing to risk all for the sake of the enhancement of humanity, who can establish his own values as the world in which others live their lives. This concept of overman absolutely goes beyond the collective consciousness and coercive power of society, but at the same time, since "overman" is superior to all and above society, should it still be considered as an inclusive part of human beings?


You also talked about how some of the social facts could constrain people to follow them, and the rebellion against these facts might cause harm to the individual. I was trying to thinking of some examples to disprove this statement when reading it, but sadly I could not think of any when it comes to cases regarding the laws, currency, marriage, or even basic social norms. Maybe someone would argue that “you do not have to get married if you do not want to, it’s all up to you”. However, the truth is that one is only allowed to do so when there is a group of individuals who come to support and stand align with him or her, which, as a matter of fact, already forms another social trend.


By Fuyuan Zheng

Comments

Popular Posts