Sociocultural Critique of Theory within Fantasy Football
BY JACK TALTON
Every year, from August to January millions of people around the US sit in the same chair every Sunday for 10 hours straight watching, managing, and talking banter regarding their fantasy football teams. It all starts by drafting “your team” and choosing “your players” to best your friends but more importantly not come in last and receive a terrible punishment. During this time of fantasy football, those who participate spend hours on hours each week deciding who to start and who to bench, based on how well they believe their players are going to perform. Along with this a sizable amount of people are consistently in front of the big screen whenever a game is on. Why is this?
I have come to several conclusions regarding why this is. First, participants want to see their team do well because fantasy football fills a competitive void that they miss from a younger age when they competed on some type of sports platform themselves and they don’t want to miss a single thing. Second, there is an entire community of fantasy football participants and NFL lovers in general and this becomes a point for conversation for members of this community or for those that want to enter which then pulls in an entirely different part of the population, those who are afraid they will lose social interaction without participating or being able to speak intellectually about the sport or about the at of participating, in terms of points, who to start, or why you made the decision you did. You can call this "FOMO" or fear of missing out but in reality, a small number of participants do it to remain in social circles or remain “in the loop” and in certain ways you can link this to Freud’s “castration complex”. In order not to be “castrated" from the group or have your social life “castrated” you join one of these leagues to keep these relationships intact. However, in doing this it creates a cycle to watching games and the combination of competitiveness and fear of castration lead to a Sunday without productivity, and after the first Sunday this happens it becomes incredibly difficult to break this cycle and ends up controlling your behavior for at the very least the rest of the season and the decision to go the library or do schoolwork becomes harder and harder every single week. This continues because not only does your status in this circle grow but your interest grows right along with it. This cycle then continues with the next person who wants to join your circle or happens again when you want to join a bigger circle with more participants and there are more social interactions to be had. From week to week during the season and post season we face different opponents which immediately brings us to using different binaries without even thinking about it such as my team and their team, I’m going to win this week because my team is good, and their team is bad even if it is just playful banner or rhetoric to try and influence or persuade someone to trade with other players in the league. These binaries might not seem obviously and might not be inherent as some theorists have speculated in the past, but we often don’t even think about what we are doing when making banter using these binaries.
While participation in fantasy football can help one find a new social circle, like any other group, however, clicks form and some members of the group are shut out or not taken seriously by the other competitors, especially if this fantasy football participant was not previously acquainted with the members of the group. This all due to the rhetoric within the hierarchy that forms throughout the fantasy football season. This rhetoric puts those with the most winningest record on a pedestal while punishing the person who comes in last, normally physically, but could punish them socially, depending on the attitude of the loser. This hierarchy is constructed rhetorically through language through words such as best or winner and worst and loser. These words separate those at the top and the bottom, and if those at the bottom let these words get to them, they face exclusion from the group in the future. This might happen if a participant is a sore loser, or if they refuse to complete the punishment. There is plenty I could say about fantasy football, but these are a few of the ways different theories might play a part in this social yet competitive activity.
Comments
Post a Comment