Socio-Cultural Critique of the rise of fit-fluencers - Cole Nikas

Cole Nikas

While the “fitness benefits” being referred to in Bird’s Costly Signaling Theory was fitness in terms of survival, it reminded me of the cultural activity of going to the gym. Every day, millions of people around the world either excitedly swing open the front doors to their gym or sit in their car debating whether they should work out 10 minutes before dragging their feet through the doors. In both scenarios, people believe that working out in the traditional sense is healthy and something they need to do. When the pandemic closed in-person gyms, however, a new type of social media influencer was born: the fitness influencer. 


We’ve all seen mirror selfies from the gym. When those selfies began talking to us and telling us exactly how we could look like them, we became obsessed. At-home workouts are now a common and well-known thing. It seems that throughout the lockdown, everyone had their favorite person to help guide them through tailored workouts in their living rooms. It is known scientifically that we should exercise regularly to stay healthy. However, many people like to take that a step further, working out certain areas of their body for cosmetic reasons. Working out isn’t even about raw strength that enhances our ability to function better at a job, sport, or hobby. It has turned into a shaping tool, a new way for humans to make themselves look as attractive or aesthetically pleasing as possible. 


This may be a result of the same phenomenon that stems from the Costly Signaling Theory. Costly Signaling Theory is the theory that in primitive societies, hunters made the seemingly illogical choice to chase more dangerous and energy-expensive animals. This resulted in a surplus of food, so they would share with the tribe. Instead of receiving financial or favor-based compensation, they received clout and reputation. These ideas are what would get them what they ultimately desire: a mate and respect from their competition. This would also solidify themselves as the best provider. Costly Signaling Theory still stands today, and we see it most overtly in the methods people use to get in shape. When we look good, we tend to attract more desirable traits in potential mates or sexual partners, and we are conditioned to think that conventionally attractive men, in particular, are more able to provide for us.


As a Survivor (tv show on CBS) superfan, I am well-acquainted with the type of people on the show who spend all of their energy spearfishing all day to bring their tribe bags and bags of fish. This is such a common role season-to-season that it is a recognizable archetype. The first-ever winner of the show, Richard Hatch, secured his spot in the tribe by reminding his tribemates that he is the one feeding them, so they loved him. Another fisherman, Ozzy Lusth, was seen as attractive by millions of fans, mostly because of his physique that allowed him to provide for his tribe. This attribute also helped him get far in the game and made him a fan favorite for seasons to come. The point is, Ozzy and Richard and many others realized that they can garner a reputation as a reward for catching the most fish, which gave them respect and made them attractive and likable.


While most of us don’t have to hunt for our food anymore (except for what they do on Survivor) we still look everywhere for ways to look like we are capable of hunting. The most common way to get fit to look good is going to the gym, but increasingly common practice is the at-home workout. Fitness influencers capitalize on this trend, and they have millions of followers, gaining cult followings from people who are just trying to signal to potential mates that they are capable of doing it all. 


Comments

Popular Posts