Socio-Cultural Critique of Ordinary Affects
By Jarrett Hall
One socio-cultural issue that both my group as well as Kathleen Stewart addresses in her book is that of the events that occurred on 9/11. This event not only changed the cultural landscape of American history forever, but also reached across all levels of social and economic status in American society as well. Stewart’s framework of understanding American culture does an exceptional job at contextualizing how the American population’s reaction to 9/11 affected the cultural structure within the U.S.
In the subsequent events that followed 9/11, the American population created a cohesive nature where shared values and beliefs of American patriotism coincided with anti-Muslim sentiments and if anyone disagreed with those shared, public feelings, they were automatically deemed as disloyal to American freedom and liberty. This also has ties to Edward Said’s film pertaining to Orientalism; as this tragic, shared experience mustered up egregious stereotypes of Muslims as being violent, irrational people. Attributing to Durkheim’s concept of the “social fact”, Stewart’s notion of collective experiences essentially bound members of American society together, which was in no small part due to this new understanding of how to act towards Middle Easterners.
In Stewart’s book, her fragmentary ethnographic observations of the American reaction to the events of 9/11 truly captures the political forces that established these anti-Muslim sentiments. She explained how “Here was the same rude awakening from an already fitful sleep. Then the double-barreled reactions of ponderous commentary and brash reaction.” She continued by the stating that “Everyone was on alert. But there was also an undercurrent of deflation, like something buoyant had been breached” (Stewart, 125). Essentially, Stewart is explaining how, before the events of 9/11, American culture had basically become arrogant to the point where it was believed America could not be threatened by any small group/nation because they were so inferior to the United States. However, after 9/11, the complete blindside of those attacks angered Americans so deeply because it was also an attack on American identity. The identity of superiority and power had, as Stewart expressed, been breached. The confidence in American society had had a violent awakening, as many Americans became not only angry, but also extremely on edge by the events that occurred. If something could happen at this large of a scale, who knows what else could happen to America? American culture had essentially gone into freefall. The socio-cultural understanding of American superiority had abruptly come to an end, although briefly.
This horrific series of events, while it did falter American’s shared beliefs of dominance, it also subsequently manifested into sentiments of animosity towards any and all Middle Easterners, regardless if they were Muslim or not. Although most people nowadays understand that this stance was objectively wrong and was just in the heat of the moment, there is still underlying prejudices towards Muslims and Middle Easterners even to this day. This can blatantly be seen in immigration laws, Hollywood films, etc. This can also be seen through something Stewart acknowledges throughout her book; where ordinary ideas and activities become significantly altered through social shifts, normally as a result of conflict which in this case, was the 9/11 attacks.
Scenes or events of impact like 9/11 deeply affected not only Americans individually but also American culture as well. The lasting imprint that 9/11 had on the population can not only be seen through the massive push towards American patriotism and Middle Eastern prejudices but can also be understood through fragmentary ethnographic experiences like Stewart lays out in her book. These shared, collective experiences, similar to Durkheimian social facts, altered American conceptions of U.S. superiority and invincibility. These social facts also bound American citizens together through a collectively tragic experience that has had lasting imprints on the U.S. socio-cultural landscape to this day. As Stewart claimed in her book, “Ordinary affects are public feelings that begin and end in broad circulation” (Stewart, 2). Although this retaliatory stance towards Middle Easterners has definitely diminished significantly since the 9/11 attacks, we also see that these public feelings of underlying Middle Eastern/Muslim biases have surely persisted in more ways than one.
Thank you for this nice piece on Stewart! The quote you pulled out in the fourth-to-last line is a great crystallization of Stewart's approach. I do think it's important to note that, as Said showed so well, 9/11 just provided for a coalescence of anti-Muslim sentiment in the U.S. It didn't initiate that trend.
ReplyDelete