Socio-Cultural Critique of Leacock

 By Jarrett Hall

Eleanor Leacock's "Interpreting the Origins of Gender Inequality" essay discussed how the origins of gender hierarchy within a society coincided with exploitation and class stratification. She argued that the biased perspective of women being viewed as subordinate to men was not a universal assumption to be made, but instead was a result of commodity production and division of labor. Essentially, the notion of female inferiority is due to the respective economic conditions that women are under within certain societies. The progress of women being viewed as subordinate was not an inherently physiological or natural condition but was instead a direct result of historical processes. In a Marxian tone, she explained how women’s labor had become a gift to capitalism, as they often worked for little to no pay compared to their male counterparts.  This labor that women produced would allow for the male workers to produce commodities, while the females would do much of the domestic work for free. Thus, women’s labor was exploited by not only their male counterparts, but the economic system of capitalism; where those who owned the means of production benefitted off of women’s labor while typically not having to pay them at all because most of their work was done as domestic labor. Leacock also explained how this gender hierarchy was a relatively new concept, as men and women in many Native American societies often equally participated in egalitarian production before their societies were unavoidably influenced by Europeans, who ultimately were the drivers behind gender inequality.

Although most societies in the world have made strides towards more fairly compensating women for their hardworking labor and diligence, we still often see a discrepancy in the wages they receive compared to their male counterparts. This can most evidently be seen in the enormous wage gap between the WNBA and the NBA in professional sports. Despite the WNBA being considered the most elite league to play basketball for women in the world, their pay grade often does not even hold a candle to their fellow NBA players. On average, WNBA player make less than $100,000 a year, while NBA players often make millions of dollars per year. Even the best and most-highest paid WNBA players do not make even close to the amount that the worst, least-paid NBA players make. This discrepancy can even be seen in NCAA basketball. Just this year, there were photos taken at the men and women’s “NCAA Tournament bubble” that showed the NCAA had set up an entire weight room full of machines, free weights, as well as other amenities for the male basketball players. However, for the women, they only received one measly dumbbell rack. If these men and women are the most talented players in the world for their respective sport and gender, then why do we see such a disparity?

Many people would point out that, in terms of the salary differential, this is based on viewership, marketability, endorsements, etc. Although this does play a huge role in the disparity, this ties back to Leacock’s explanation that women’s labor is often the gift to the capitalist economy. The people who own the means of production, which in this case would be the owners of the teams, make hundreds of millions of dollars just by simply benefitting off of owning a professional sports team and the labor that these women put in. Obviously, in a Marxian sense, the NBA players also get exploited for their labor by the team owners as well, however, they get compensated much more handsomely for their efforts than the women do. This new insight on the economic aspect of gender inequality in professional basketball is something that correlates to Leacock’s understanding of capitalistic exploitation of women’s labor in society. This is no doubt related to the historical stereotype of women being inferior athletes, and subsequently, inferior laborers compared to their male counterpart. Although there seems to be no tangible answer to solving this wage gap in the sports world currently, theorists like Leacock certainly display how this is only one aspect of a much more vast historical process of subordinating women in an economically-driven gender hierarchy in our society.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular Posts