Socio-Cultural Critique of Exit Zero
BY: LISETTE VICTORIA SAN PEDRO
Exit Zero by Christine Walley is an autoethnography which uses personal narrative to describe and systematically analyze her experiences of growing up in Southeast Chicago. In 1980, during her adolescence, the steel mills in Southeast Chicago were abruptly shut down and her community underwent a process of deindustrialization, which is the decline in industrial activity. Although, Walley’s intimate retellings of her cultural upbringings surrounded the Southeast side, the United States underwent deindustrialization on a national scale. Moreover, through Walley’s personal narrative, she positions herself within greater society through the mobilization of Neo-Marxist theory and Practice Theory.
Neo-Marxism looks at both the individual and social structures within one’s environment. This differentiates from Marxism that focuses solely on political economy, specifically capitalism’s role in shaping social life. Neo-Marxism illustrates an economic system that creates a wealthy class of owners and a poor class of workers. Not to mention, the wealthy class maintains institutions that create divisions between the powerful and the powerless. For instance, between middle and upper-class liberals and conservatives, Walley observed a contrasting stereotype of the working class. Not only do many of these individuals lack the friendship of any working-class citizens, but conservatives also romanticize workers for their genuine appeal, while liberals write them off as a characterization of their flaws, i.e., racist, and sexist attitudes. In Walley’s investigation to understand these stereotypes, she connects her personal anecdotes to the culture at hand. Walley recollects many of the women in her community were actively antifeminist and valued ‘traditional’ gender roles to maintain social capital. However, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century, the Victorian middle class espoused a ‘cult of domesticity' which emphasized the need for mothers in the home. In this case, the inability of the working class and immigrant women to stay home was often linked to the degradation of their social status. Therefore, the ability to stay at home and rely on a family wage centered around the man was a privilege and a symbol of upward mobility. Moreover, gendered labor then affected families experiencing deindustrialization because not only were family structures unprepared for women to be away from the home, but it was degrading for individuals to publicly lose social status. In sum, the usage of Neo-Marxism to critique the understanding of gender within a Capitalist society allowed Walley to understand how individual actions are often the result of inherited structures.
Practice theory is strongly associated with the theorist Pierre Bourdieu and it seeks to explain the social and cultural world by analyzing behaviors that interconnect to form groups, lifestyles, networks, and other social groups. Bourdieu outlines the idea of habitus, which is the physical embodiment of cultural capital by way of deeply ingrained habits, skills, and dispositions that one possessed from their environment. Walley then contrasts her known habitus to that of people she meets in her private, university. Her observed contradictions between her middle-class embodied culture and those of her upper-middle-class peers, allows her to position social class outside of Southeast Chicago. Additionally, Walley contrasts her experience as a white middle-class student to that of African American students and concludes that although their racial status was easily observed as different, she often faded into the background. She was largely faced by differences in classroom settings, where her confidence lacked because of her ‘incorrect’ English. Much of her fear of judgment not only stemmed from her dialect but when she would attempt to speak on her life experiences, her situation was considered a ‘downer’. Walley felt like an outsider, was plagued with survivor’s guilt, and extreme anger towards a community that took privilege for granted. Her differentiated habitus compared to rich students, left her feeling culturally incompatible. Not to mention, as a scholarship student, she was selected to give a speech to alumni. Although, she intended her speech to be understood as one of anger for the injustices that are ignored in working-class cities, the privileged alumni heard her speech through the popular narrative that America is the land of opportunity. In this case, Walley’s use of Practice Theory was beneficial because pushed the idea that reality and truth are constructed depending on environmental upbringings. More so, her in-depth, intimate self-analysis allowed for readers to reconstruct her behavior, thoughts, emotions, and other large aspects of her habitus.
Those wanting to understand the role of practice theory in Walley's book, READ THIS. The statement that Walley shows how "individual actions are often the result of inherited structures" really gets to the heart of the matter. Thank you, Lisette Victoria!
ReplyDelete