Socio-Cultural Critique -- Foucault’s Theory of Power and Knowledge: Western Biomedicine

By Haley Smith

One of the central features of postmodern anthropological theory is understanding knowledge to be highly cultural, inherently biased and tethered to power. Michel Foucault understood knowledge to be “information linked to social discourses of power” (HAT 160). He argued that even scientific knowledge should be understood as a product of power, history and culture. Science, particularly medicine, is inextricably linked to postcolonial Western power which has developed authoritative medical institutions that incite a cultural understanding of “health” onto the general populace. Science, which is foundational to medicine, is often understood as an abstract pillar of truth that can be used to recognize and fight real illnesses. More specifically, Western biomedicine is a cultural institution that derives authority from the notion that it is impervious to the irrationality of human cultural practice. This fundamental characteristic of biomedicine is what makes it so powerful and difficult to challenge. Western biomedical practices are thus articulated as unbiased methods that uncover truths that exist in the natural world. However, the idea that biomedicine is null of cultural influence should be understood as highly cultural itself. It is critical to remember that biomedical institutions have the power to determine what is an “illness” and what is not. In many cases, this ability to define health and deviance can be seen as a harnessing of power rather than an application of science. This is not to say the biomedicine itself is not a highly effective tool for reducing psychological and bodily affliction, but rather to shed light on the culturally infused nature of western medicine and its power to determine “illness” and “health”. 

Foucault argues that “knowledge is primarily a way of naming and ordering the world that favors the powerful and seeks to maintain the status quo” (HAT 163).  In this light, western biomedicine has been mobilized by those in power to maintain cultural norms and promote subjective notions of morality. For example, masturbation was once understood to be a disease with symptoms and real medical cures. “Masturbation was held to be the cause of dyspepsia, constrictions of the urethra, epilepsy, blindness, vertigo, loss of hearing, head-ache, impotency, loss of memory...” (Engelhardt 236). Additionally, medical case studies were published which determined masturbation to be a product of insanity as well as having injurious effects on the reproductive system (Engelhardt 237). Here we see science as something highly influenced by the cultural and moral makeup of the 19th century United States. Today, the supposed health problems associated with masturbation have been completely inverted. If you look up “health benefits of masturbation”, pages of medical sites appear with lists of bodily and psychological benefits. For example, Healthline states, “Masturbation is a healthy sexual activity. It has many benefits for your physical and mental health.” It follows this statement with a bullet list including better sleep, mood booster, stress relief, and cramp relief. The switch in medical opinion over masturbation illustrates the science is not out of culture’s reach but is rather borne of it, informed by it and affected by it. 

Postmodernism’s understanding of knowledge as something conditioned by culture, history and context as well as controlled by those in power has allowed for the emergence of medical anthropology. Medical anthropology, “the study of the social and cultural dimensions of health and illness” (HAT 168), has played a critical role in exposing the highly cultural nature of allopathic medicine, which is too often articulated as an objective practice. 

Comments

  1. Hi Haley! I thought your socio-cultural critique on Western biomedicine was extremely on point and does a great job of demonstrating Foucault’s theory of knowledge as a product of power, history, and culture. As you point out, science is the basis of Western biomedicine, and this often leads to the claim that it is infallible and objective. However, if one were to look back even just a few decades, it becomes clear that scientific theories can be incorrect, and in many cases they are influenced by dominant cultural narratives. The best example I can think of is from early uses of physical anthropology, where colonizers would use skull size and shape to infer intelligence, bravery, civility etc. and then attribute those qualities to a certain race. Because white colonists were looking for a way to solidify their “divine right to rule” those desirable qualities were attributed to white people, and negative qualities were extrapolated from skull shapes associated with people of color. After actual research was conducted on this idea, it quickly became clear that this “scientific” theory had no actual evidence to support it. This system of knowledge went unquestioned for years, and it was ultimately just the product of colonial interests and power. So, while modern Western medicine does have a more scientifically sound basis, there are still many instances where it acts as a support for the current power structure. In Dr. Bender’s language and social justice class, one of the readings talked about an indigenous group (I believe that it was somewhere in South America, but this could be wrong) had an outbreak of some kind that was causing their children to become extremely ill. After their local medicine was unable to combat the illness, they began taking their children to hospitals that practiced Western biomedicine. The biggest problem was that the doctors would only ask certain questions and once they had their answers they would stop communicating with the parents. Within the system of medicine, the only knowledge that was recognized and utilized came from individuals that had gone through formal schooling (which is a structure of power). I think that Foucault would find fault with this system because part of post-structuralism is the celebration of “subjugated knowledges” that are often pushed to the margins. Instead of just looking for information that is deemed important by the dominant Western culture, it would have been more beneficial to listen to what the indigenous parents had to say, as this could have provided insights as to where or how their children contracted the illness.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great discussion, Haley and Josh! Thank you.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts