Socio-Cultural Critique: Exit Zero and Deindustrialization in Winston-Salem

 Deindustrialization has been sweeping across the United States, beginning in earnest in the late 1970s, and growing exponentially worse as the decades go by. Factories have been steadily closing, and the manufacturing economy that once defined America has been gradually replaced with an economy built on the knowledge and service industries. While this change is often framed as a good thing, the detrimental effects on the working class have long been ignored, and it is vital that the problems of deindustrialization are recognized, and its victims acknowledged. These impacts are readily seen in our own city of Winston-Salem. The city was once a famous industrial center, home to the factories of Hanes Textiles and RJ Reynolds Tobacco. Now, these factories and their manufacturing jobs are all but gone, and the “revitalization” of the city has been centered around the Biotech and service industries. The parallels to Christine Walley’s Exit Zero are uncanny and demonstrate how pervasive the issue of deindustrialization is in the United States. Walley’s Neo-Marxian and Post Structuralist approaches to studying deindustrialization and revitalization in South East Chicago provide an excellent framework for examining these same processes that are happening in Winston-Salem.

First, it is important to recognize the history of the region and how this shaped the job industry in the city. With their construction in the 1890s and early 1900s, RJ Reynolds Tobacco and Hanes Mills dominated the job market in Winston-Salem, and collectively employed tens of thousands of people. The history of these factories can help explain why the region was so dependent on them as well as why their loss would create such a devastating impact on the local economy. Also, for the large African American population in North Carolina, “dirty jobs”, like tobacco processing, were often the only ways for them to earn an income due to the history of racism in the South. The historical funneling of African Americans into these factory jobs led to the general trend of people in Winston-Salem finishing their education with a high school degree or less and then immediately moving into the manufacturing industry. Once these factory jobs left the city, the people in WS did not meet the qualifications for the various service jobs and high-tech jobs that moved in.

Second, Walley contributes to the post-structural critique of social structures and acknowledges that they are not always designed to benefit everyone within a give society. Walley gives the example of Chicago’s plans to repurpose the Calumet region for either coal gasification plants or environmental and economic rehabilitation. The problem, she states, is that both of these plans push the working-class citizens of the region to the margins: neither of the plans are geared specifically toward them. This is very similar to the current revitalization plans for Winston-Salem. The City-County Planning Board of Winston-Salem’s Legacy 2030 Comprehensive Plan lays out a plan for improving the city in terms of land use, health, environmental quality, transportation, and economic growth. Chapter six covers the plans for economic development, and it is primarily focused on bringing in new, highly educated, and skilled workers while largely ignoring the current labor force that already lives in the city. The plan frequently mentions how its main goal is to attract companies that are engaged in progressive research and professional service, listing the Wake Forest Innovation Quarter as a beacon for biotech and medical research companies. Under their list of polices, the bullet point about housing says, “encourage development of housing and accompanying retail services to attract researchers and other professionals to live in downtown Winston-Salem.” The whole plan for revitalization is built on the premise that new, highly educated, financially well-off individuals will move to Winston-Salem, and little to no accommodations have been made for the impoverished people that are already here.

This blatant disregard for the poorer, working-class citizens of WS is also compounded by the city’s infrastructure, specifically highway 52. This freeway was constructed in the 50s during as a part of “urban renewal” and it runs directly through the black and brown neighborhoods of Winston-Salem, effectively cutting off the people in East Winston-Salem from all of these “beneficial” developments happening in downtown. So, not only is the new economy being created in Winston-Salem completely avoiding manufacturing jobs, neglecting the working-class which was hit the hardest by deindustrialization, but the people that so desperately need these jobs don’t even have physical access to them.

Walley’s Neo-Marxian and Post-Structuralist approach allows us to form a clearer picture of what is happening in Winston-Salem as well as other cities that are undergoing this process of deindustrialization and revitalization. By examining the histories of these cities as well as critiquing their current social structures, we are able to understand how they ended up in their current economic position, and we can ensure that the people most victimized by deindustrialization are no longer forgotten in plans to improve the social and economic environment.

Josh Milon

Comments

  1. Thanks for this great application of Walley's perspective! It is so important to have a critical understanding of the place we live in.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Josh, I really appreciated this analysis of Winston Salem and its connection to Exit Zero. I didn’t read the book, but I do feel like I know quite a bit about some of the gentrification and structural access (food deserts, lack of access to healthcare facilities, etc.) problems in the area. My research last summer looked at unequal flow of COVID cases throughout the Winston-Salem area, and we found a clear correlation between race, income, and percentage of cases. There is great disparity within various areas of W-S; some zip codes have annual incomes of more than $100,000 per household, and others are as low as $24,000 per household or so. As much as I know about the existing inequality within the city, I didn’t really know about how the new laws and initiatives passed by the city were impacting the livelihood of working class residents. It seems clear that the city is prioritizing more of a knowledge and service-based economy, but this “leaves behind” many of its residents. While there are still some spaces for unskilled labor, such as the meat packing plants north and south of the city, many of the new jobs rely on education or experience that the average person might not have. Winston Salem seems to want to intentionally shift away from these types of jobs, but this is unequally beneficial to some of its residents. This greater analysis of the way that structures impact the everyday lives of ordinary citizens is super interesting because we can directly see the ways that the system is not set up for certain people to succeed. Thanks so much for helping contextualize the theoretical work of Walley with the area we are involved with during our four years here!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts