SOCIAL-CULTURAL CRITIQUE: SHOULD YOUNG BOYS BE IN THE FEMALE RESTROOM?
BY FREYA ZHENG
Recently, there has been a controversial discussion going on in Chinese social media. The conversation starts with a group of unmarried females grumbling about those mothers who have to take their opposite-sex children into women's restroom in public places like shopping malls. According to their comments, these unmarried ladies feel uncomfortable and irritated seeing boys being in the supposed-to-be female-only place, especially in the case that some mothers are too busy taking care of their kids so that they forget to lock the toilet compartment door. When these complaints and requests to not take their opposite-sex kids into the female restroom were exposed on social media, the discussion turned into an unexpected direction. The married women who have a son argue that most of the time they have no other choice besides taking their child into the female bathroom because the fathers are usually not with them. They also blame those single women for not being able to put themselves in other ones' shoes. The unmarried feminists, feeling humiliated and disrespected, respond resentfully by indicating that those married mothers have lost their self-worth as females and stood in the males' camp with their husbands and sons.
Gradually, the focal point of this discussion has switched from "the importance of establishing unisex restroom at public places" to "the rivalry between married women and single women". Where does this simmering hostility between single women and married women come from? Many married women see single women as failures because they have not married and given birth to a boy so that their lives are less worthy of respect. At the same time, many single and feminist women look at married women as being in prison, lacking freedom, and subordinate to the male roles in the family. Some of them would even say, "if those moms think it is okay to bring their son, a male, into a 'female' bathroom, then why don't they, as females, just take their son to the male bathroom with them?"
Regardless of how unreasonable this is under the bathroom bill and morality, we could actually see the concept of symbolism and structuralism in this one question. "No males should be allowed in a place with a female sign and called 'female' restroom," said these single women. Under the cultural and societal influences, the "female" and "male" sign (both language and image) as signifier have been tightly connected with the idea of gender binarism (the signified) in people's minds and behaviors. According to Saussure, a sign, the basic unit of language, is a psychological entity where a signifier (sound-image) and a signified (concept) are arbitrarily linked. This arbitrariness of the signs and sex binarism, in this case, would contribute to the argument held by those who don't accept opposite-sex kids in public restrooms. However, in the current Chinese patriarchal society where the unisex bathroom has not been fully promoted, this only adds more challenges to the situation of married women, who are always expected to fulfill their female gender roles at home.
The term gender role refers to society's concept of how men and women are expected to act and how they should behave. These roles are constructed based on norms or standards created by society throughout history. Structural-Functionalists argue that gender roles were established well before the preindustrial era when men typically took care of responsibilities outside of the home, such as hunting, and women typically took care of the domestic responsibilities in or around the home. These roles were considered functional because women were often limited by the physical restraints of pregnancy and nursing. Once established, these roles were passed on to subsequent generations since they served as an effective means of keeping the family system functioning properly. As we grow, we learn how to behave from those around us.
When looking at this ongoing disputation between single and married women, it is not hard to find that not so many males are involved in the discourse. None of them cares about "what should dads do when they need to take their daughter to the restroom" simply because they do not need to. Many Chinese males and females take for granted that the responsibility of taking good care of kids mostly lies on a mother's shoulder. Patriarchy and misogyny are as ingrained in the DNA of some women as it is in their male counterparts; the married women internalize it because they believe it forms the very foundation of the social structure. Family, education, peer groups, and mass media, each agent reinforces gender roles by creating and maintaining normative expectations or even requirements for gender-specific behaviors.
Post-structuralist and feminist anthropologists, leading by Judith Butler, have long struggled with the idea that the division of humans has two and only two categories, “male” and “female". Instead, they state that “male” and “female” are cultural concepts that take different forms and have different meanings cross-culturally. It is understandable that the feminists want to fight for their deserved space by arguing against the only choice left for the married mothers. However, under the current Chinese cultural context, these feminist single ladies who advocate for gender equality somehow ignore the fact that the arbitrary separation of “men” and “women” in public restrooms could adversely impact the progression of what we should define as “equality”. This sort of exclusive separation leads to the marginalization of not only those who are transgender but even also mothers with a male kid.
Personally, I don't have a definite answer to the question because no matter which group I stand with, both of them are just striving after their own right and properties. As an Asian woman myself, I do not have the courage and determination to judge each side and say one of them is wrong. However, I do believe that women ourselves must be the catalyst of change. What society looks like in the future depends on how we shape it. To fight the system which basically allows men a free ticket to escape the responsibilities of the family that they also share, married women need to stick with their own rights and believe in the equality that they deserve.

This was really fascinating on so many levels. Thinking about the situation in terms of post-structuralist theory is particularly insightful. Thank you!
ReplyDelete