SOCIAL-CULTURAL CRITIQUE: POSTMODERNIMST ANALYSIS OF PICTURE-TAKING BEHAVIORS IN CURRENT ART MUSEUMS
BY FUYUAN ZHENG
An art museum or art gallery is the term describing a space for the exhibition of visual art. Since the world’s first art museum opened in the 16th century, museums have always been the go-to heaven for inspiration and knowledge, especially for those “culture vultures” who profess great interest in culture and the arts. In great metropolises, art galleries and contemporary art museums have become increasingly popular these years, accompanied by the emerging new culture of “picture-taking” in these museums full of abstract or unprecedented creative artwork.
One great thing about 21st-century museum practice is that, with very few exceptions, visitors can photograph absolutely anything in the collections, in any form, and post them to any platform they want. Especially now with the development of cell phone cameras, it has become increasingly common to see people taking pictures in art museums without turning the flash on. However, looking at the pictures, it is surprisingly found that the subjects of the photographs are not the artwork but rather people themselves dressing up and posing artistically. Hashtags like #ArtSelfies and #MuseumSelfies have also been continuously trending on social media since not long ago.
According to related journals and interviews, three facts about this “picture-taking” trends can be generalized: (1) the visitors do not have to know the historic or artistic background of each artwork to make it the background of their pictures; (2) picture-taking has almost become an integral part of one’s art museum experience, and some would use it as a standard to evaluate the quality of an exhibition; and (3) museums and artists, who have tasted the sweetness of this new trend of picture-taking, might intentionally curate the exhibition in a way that caters to audience’s preference, for instance, the inclusion of lighting and shadow, or magnifying artwork into an immense proportion.
These three points, coincidently or not, perfectly correspond to the tenets of postmodernism in this case. Firstly, since there is no unbiased knowledge, it is unfair to blame these “image-makers” for not knowing the “right answer” to the art piece. It really is the freedom of the audience themselves to decide how they would like to “curate” their museum experience and even their life. Secondly, postmodernists state that people must realize that power is implicated in knowledge. In contemporary art, then, the power is implied through the way artists and curators create an art exhibition, through which they impose their intentions and willingness to the audience who would unconsciously or consciously receive their knowledge during the visit. At the same time, the practice (praxis) that a museum takes also has the power to influence people’s understanding and perceptions of art. Thirdly, building on the concept of symbolic anthropology, culture can be seen as a text or performance. Similarly, art exhibitions, in some circumstances, can also be considered as a text or performance brought by both the artists and the audience. An art exhibition cannot exist without its audience, and the formation of this performance must consist of both the art piece itself and the interpretation from a spectator. Postmodernism supports the idea that there is no definitive interpretation of an art piece, and all the interpretation is essentially self-referential.
Some museum workers contend that it is a pleasure to see museums “staying relevant in the digital age by acknowledging, adapting to, and embracing visitor behaviors''. Being in this age of hyper-documentation, “living an experience” is already tightly intertwined with the behavior of “photographing with a device and posting something on social media''. This combination of “photograph and post”, featuring its popularity and the symbolic meaning of “I was here”, has been named “check-in culture” in modern Chinese metropolises like Shanghai.
In this post-modern and post-digital age we live in, people “curate” their lives to present to the public, especially through social media. The convenience and quickness of social media catalyzed people’s need for recognition from others, which is shown from every detail of their pictures, including fine make-up, fashionable dressing, intentional posing for pictures, filtering and picture editing, and so on. Even on more serious occasions, people feel comfortable posting pictures of themselves without knowing the culture or understanding the concept, which also relates to the theory of postmodernism in art. In the context of postmodernism, there are no “ranking” systems in place for art, and multiple values are equally dispersed through all forms. Art and art museums can be interpreted or even reinterpreted by the visitors themselves, and meaning is derived according to the individual experience of one’s own. For me, the study of the relationship between visitors, museums, and art is going to be a continued and live experience. I am ready to see how this new culture of picture-taking within the younger generation evolves in the next decade.

Nice! Thanks.
ReplyDelete