Response to Ruohan's Critique of "The Making of Maori".
BY: LISETTE VICTORIA SAN PEDRO
Hi Ruohan,
I really like your connection between “The Making of Maori”
and “The Ecological Indian” debate. Connecting Hanson’s “tradition is now
understood … to be an invention designed to serve contemporary purposes” and
Kretch and Ranco’s debate over the false ecological narrative is a great parallel
to understand. I also think it is important to note Ranco’s argument over
Kretch’s when understanding the Maori’s internalization of the Great Fleet and
lo cult. As the Maoris adopted the tradition in order to obtain full control of
their political sovereignty, Ranco sees the identity mechanisms operating in
taking on cultural arguments to combat colonizers’ hegemonic impositions. Ranco
sites Marshall Sahlin’s practice of culturalism as the people’s attempt to
control their relationship with the dominant society. This aids in increasing
the control of technical and political means that were once used to victimize
them. I believe that Sahlin’s use of culturalism is likened to Hanson’s use of
social reproduction which is the authentication process of invented cultural
practices to ‘traditions’. Additionally, Hanson classifies social reproduction
as a case of sign-substitution, where the onset of an idea is changed by doing away
with the binary between the signifier and the signified. An example outside of
the Maori, would be the very essence of the Ecological Indian. Native Americans
normalized a stereotype rooted in colonial understandings by transforming the
signified as something that can aid in environmental conservationism. Furthermore,
by characterizing their sustainability within the context of colonial practices,
it protects people from further colonial imposition even if these tools are
weak and mythical. Again, this trend mimics the Maoris purposeful traditional distortion
to remain closed off and culturally incompatible to imperialist desires.
Thank you for enriching the connections to theory here and for the additional context on the "ecological Indian"!
ReplyDelete