Response to Haley's Critique of Mattingly's Luck, Friendship, and the Narrative Self"
BY JACK TALTON
I would agree with Haley’s point that self-reflection is central to the process of growing and healing after the devastating effects of an accident such as the one Mattingly describes. Mattingly continues to go back and forth between the actions being taken both by Dolores and Sasha, to make things “normal” for Willy. For example, Dolores tries to normalize seeing himself and being content with how he looks as well as show Willy how to deal with people who might make fun of him for it. We can see most clearly the impact of Dolores when Willy goes to school and uses his wit to combat the bullies and those making fun of how he looks. Sasha however, after the accident first occurred tried to hide Willy from his appearance and hide him from himself essentially, thinking this would protect him. What would be interesting to know, is who has more of an impact on the other, Sasha on Willy or Willy on Sasha? Because of Mattingly’s piece being centered mostly on how Sasha herself has to transform it might seem as if Willy might have had more of an impact on her. However, as Haley mentions in her critique, which I hadn’t really thought about was that Mattingly wrote a good amount about the efforts of Dolores and Sasha and the transformations Sasha went through, but Willy really was a side character in his own story. If Mattingly did choose to add Willy’s point of view on all the events that transpired, it would give us further insight his relationships with Sasha and Dolores and could possibly answer the question I introduced.
Comments
Post a Comment