Response to Haley's Critique of Douglas
By Jarrett Hall
I completely agree with Haley's analysis of the social hierarchy within the Hindu caste system. Douglas explains in her essay that the Hindu caste is like a body; where the head (Brahmins) do the thinking, and the despised parts (Dalits) deal with waste matter. This is a form of body symbolism (Douglas, 428). This also displays that bodily boundaries are metaphorical to Hindu societal boundaries. Another criticism that Douglas addresses in her essay that interested me is that of Bruno Bettelheim. Her criticism stems from his tendency to treat non-Western people as childlike or mentally ill. He uses influences from Freud to explain how these "primitive cultures" are the equivalent to Freud's infant stage of the human psyche. He also believes that these "savage people" would be more complex like Westerners if they solved problems through "alloplastic manipulation" instead of "autoplastic"; essentially that they are incapable of complex thinking and are infant-like. This is similar to Norman O. Brown's Freudian concept that ritual usage of the body/bodily substances relates to non-Western indigenous people being in a culturally evolutionary stage similar to that of the stage for infant anal eroticism. She carefully explained that these stances are biased and "psychological explanations cannot of their nature account for what is culturally distinctive phenomena" (Douglas, 424-426). I like the way you described Douglas's argument, great post!
Comments
Post a Comment