Reading Critique of Leacock's "Interpreting the Origins of Gender Inequality" - Cole Nikas
By: Cole Nikas
In “Interpreting the Origins of Gender Inequality,” Leacock uses other anthropological works to build her history of gender inequality. Her writing strategy was to analyze priorly written works from well-known ethnographers and disprove notions of women’s role in society that insinuated or directly stated that women are inherently and universally going to be assessed as subordinate and inferior to men. Her role as a feminist and as a Marxist is evident right away, as the first paragraph outlines her argument and her issue with the likes of Levi-Strauss, and she clearly indicates that one of the main reasons we are having issues with gender inequality today is due to his characterization of women as a historical commodity, meant to be bought and sold.
One of Leacocks’s main critiques is that ethnographers rarely study cultural history further than whatever notion they had of the culture in question’s history going into the ethnography. We are all operating under preconceived notions, like Levi-Strauss's characterization of women as a commodity in antiquity, and we ignore the likes of Marx, who may have more accurately (according to Leacock) made capitalism the scapegoat for gender inequality.
The idea of primitive communism is of utmost importance to know when reading Leacock’s work. Primitive communism is an idea started by Henry Morgan and elaborated on and adopted by Marx and Engels. Morgan originally discussed how early societies were communal and fair, treating the players within the society as equal and on the same tier. Marx and Engles wanted to prove the idea that communism was the natural step to take following a capitalist society because we will outgrow our capital and potential for new labor and resources and eventually have to revert back to communism, something that is innate and inherent because we were communist at the very roots of our history. She referenced historical studies on gender roles in Native American Societies to prove that non-capitalist societies have women with a more engaged role in the economy and in production. Therefore, women have been exploited for their work by men, which is the real problem at the root of inequality and the origins of gender hierarchy.
The limitations of this work are hard for me to point out because I actually agree with Leacock. I don’t see many limitations of her argument. The limitations exist in her writing. It was difficult to follow this work, as Leacock’s structure was somewhat repetitive or some of her references were either unnecessary for her point to come across or off-topic. She also perpetuates the notion that indigenous were “primitive” in assigning their communities (which were highly complex and nuanced) as “primitive communism.” It was a good point, but I came away thinking Leacock could have been a bit more accurate in her assumptions about the indigenous peoples of North America and Australia.
We can take away so much from this article. We often tend to say “well, that's just the way it is and always has been” instead of actually solving issues of modern inequality. We have so much more to learn about the origins of society’s problems by studying history more accurately and finding the culprit behind why we have issues between groups of people today.
Comments
Post a Comment