Reading Critique of "The Hunting Handicap" by Bird et al. - Cole Nikas

 By: Cole Nikas

Bird, Bird, and Smith in their article “The Hunting Handicap: Costly Signaling in Human Foraging Strategies” attempt to explain human behavior that goes against instinct and logic. It’s no uncommon knowledge that in the most primitive and archaic societies, humans hunted and gathered to provide food for themselves and feed their families. However, as society got more advanced a phenomenon occurred that seemed to go against all logic and thought. Hunters began hunting bigger animals, which cost more energy to track, kill, carry, skin, cook, and distribute among members of the tribe. What about human nature influenced us to begin sharing our rewards with society? There has to be some gain in that situation, whether it be long-term or short-term. Humans did not just start hunting bigger, more dangerous animals, risking their lives and spending all of their energy just to provide for everyone for fun. There was something they received from all this risky behavior and energy expenditure. Enter, Costly Signaling. 


As it turns out, the theory behind costly signaling explains the same phenomenon as someone going to the gym to impress another person. For simplicity’s sake, we will be comparing male hunters to the females they are looking to attract, as this article does not include the possibilities of same-sex attraction. Costly Signaling Theory refers to the idea that signals can provide fitness benefits when costs are honestly linked to signal quality and these benefits are broadcast to potential mates and competitors. In simpler terms, the hunters identify the signal (taking the more impressive prize home to the village) can give them a physically superior athletic profile, which will attract the most desirable mates and will solidify them as superior in relation to other hunters. In even more simple terms, when a man hunts more impressive animals and brings it back to everyone, they can brag to everyone about the size of their kill and how ripped they’ve gotten from the hunt. Women will want them, men will want to be them. This is a seemingly complex thought for a hunter to have in this society, but the article shows that it is human nature and signaling that led hunters to share with the village for the compensation of a good reputation and popularity. This is a more advanced form of survival because when surrounded by people who adore us, we feel safe, and people are looking out for us. This is why today, we will do nice things for others. When we analyze it in this way, it seems like doing things for others is inherently selfish, but it consists of subconscious decisions, making it more socially acceptable to expect people to like you for being nice. 


The limitations could be summed up in that this is somewhat designed to be a scientific anthropological/psychological study, yet it takes many liberties in deciding absolutes about humans and coming to definitive conclusions. As anthropologists, we typically make assertions about human behavior in social groups based on multiple studies, so the points made seemed a bit ambitious. However, I agree with the Costly Signaling Theory, and it makes sense.

Comments

Popular Posts