READING CRITIQUE OF DERRIDA’S “STRUCTURE, SIGN, AND PLAY IN THE DISCOURSE OF THE HUMAN SCIENCES”

Within this work, Jacques Derrida offers a meta-critique of the language that we use to describe other cultures, and our own. The central argument of the piece is that our discourses about problematic topics are inherently problematic because they rely on linguistic structures and vocabulary that was put in place in problematic ways. 

Derrida challenges the understanding of culture as defined by structures and signs. He argues that the structure is created around the center, but the center does not actually exist. Therefore, the work is a critique of structuralism, specifically, that of Saussure. He claims that a center to the structure does not exist, meaning that it all falls apart. Thus, discourses are created, rather than structures, because the central thing that is signified is just not there. Derrida uses this conclusion to critique the work of modern social science, or as he calls it, human sciences, because he shows that these discourses are trapped within the boundaries they have put in place for themselves. Furthermore, these “closed” circles reshape our understanding of other elements within because there is no separate or removed way to discuss these things. 

This is a post-structural interpretation because it critiques a structural understanding of culture. Many structuralists attempt to criticize Levi-Strauss and Saussure, and Derrida makes a point to address the shortcomings of Saussure’s understanding of culture. Saussure claims that signs are given meaning through their relationship within larger linguistic circles. The signifier-signified relationship is reexamined by Derrida, and he finds it to be insufficient in describing cultural phenomena. More specifically, he criticizes the way that we rely on discourses built upon problematic history. He also brings up the floating signifier, in which the relationship between the signifier and signified is not always clear. This is because the relationship has become so ideological that there is no sensory aspect. This is what Derrida is referring to when he says that certain ‘centers’ do not actually exist. These centers have had changing meanings over time, which can sometimes create a problematic history associated with various signs and entire discourses.

I believe that this work was clearly influencing and influenced by the larger postmodern movement within anthropology because it recognizes the ways in which none of the discourses that we use are separate from the power structures that have created them. This can be really powerful to recognize as anthropologists because we can be aware of the ways that our language makes assumptions about the things that we are studying. We can better understand the ways that our language frames our knowledge of certain topics, whether it is as broad as culture itself or as specific as a certain event. 

Meilyn

Comments

  1. Very nice. Point of clarification: I think you mean "many post-structuralists critique L-S and Saussure . . . "?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts