POSTMODERN SOCIO-CULTURAL ANALYSIS OF CONSPIRACY THEORIES

 Conspiracy theories have become major parts of our society. Nearly everyone has heard of the flat earthers, or the Illuminati. It is so easy to fall down internet rabbit holes researching “evidence” for different conspiracies, and there are entire online communities dedicated to furthering the legitimacy of their theories.

I would argue that conspiracy theories have a distinctly postmodern theoretical framework in the worst possible way. After reading anthropological works in the postmodern era, it is clear that evaluation of power structures and dynamics can be extremely important. For example, the ways that our current systems of knowledge are deeply entrained within power structures is something that we need to evaluate. We need to examine the who and why of ethnography. Eliminating bias and problematic history is not necessarily possible in some discourses, but acknowledging them is. Postmodernism gave way to reflexivity, which is, in my opinion, one of the greatest expressions of academic integrity there is. Instead of trying (and failing) to be objective, why don’t we explain our own theoretical leanings and biases so that the reader clearly understands the kind of work we are doing? Claiming to be objective can be harmful in many cases, since such objectivity does not exist in the postmodern doctrine. 

However, there are definitely some harmful ways that the major tenets of postmodernism can be interpreted, and the world of conspiracy theories seems to be one of the clearest examples of this. The first major claim of postmodernism, that no knowledge is unbiased, has now been re-interpreted as no knowledge is real. Postmodernism claims that no knowledge is removed from its historical and cultural context, but conspiracy theorists often take this a step further to argue that objective fact just does not exist. That way, “evidence” that disputes their theories is simply disregarded. Anecdotal evidence (and personal experience) reigns supreme over ‘scientific’ inquiry. One prime example that I think of in this instance is the Anti-Vaxxing conspiracy theory. Despite much evidence to the contrary, many people seem to believe that vaccination is linked to mental disabilities and other illnesses. It is clear that postmodernism and its skepticism of facts that are presented as objective truth but are probably not has contributed to this suspicion of legitimate medical research.

The second tenet of postmodernism is that power is implicated in knowledge. Postmodernism attempts to explain that ethnography and knowledge is generated by the powerful. It understands that history is written by those in charge, and the concept of academic authority is sometimes problematic. As anthropologists, we attempt to examine our own privilege and biases in our work in order to actively work to not play into these power dynamics. However, conspiracy theorists seem to embrace the idea that knowledge is generated by the powerful. Instead of examining this from a position of power (“How can I represent this group well, knowing my own background and theirs?”), they view it from a position of exploitation (“How are the facts being misrepresented to me by those in charge?”). The best example that I can think of is the theories about the Illuminati. (Admittedly, I don’t know much about this particular conspiracy theory, but I’m doing my best to understand.) It seems that conspiracy theorists are convinced that there are organization members at the top of every major government, entertainment, business, etc. that have a great deal of influence. Therefore, what we know to be true may not be because every facet of knowledge is controlled by a group that is trying to trick us. Of course, this would be a massively impressive feat to pull off, but I honestly don’t see how it would even be possible. Especially in the age of the internet, it seems that power (especially of the entertainment sort) is so fragmented that there is no way for everyone to trace back to the Illuminati. Still, conspiracy theorists continue to cast doubt on real-world events because they do not trust that the sources of knowledge they receive can be trusted. 

Meilyn

Comments

  1. Agreed! Postmodern thinking has been hijacked and taken in some unfortunate directions.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts