False Consciousness in Walley's "Exit Zero"

    An aspect of Walley’s text that strikes me is the complex relationship between ethnic groups who shared a common locus of life – the steel mill -- yet aimed to distinguish themselves from one another in a manner that seems somewhat counterintuitive. In the first part of her ethnographic narrative, Walley recalls that when questioned in regards to his ethnic origins, her Appalachian “Little Grandpa” would “answer angrily that we are American, goddamn it!” (Walley, 2013, 36). Looking beyond this phrase as a form of “ethnic antagonism”, Walley observes that Little Grandpa’s response may serve as a form of “defensiveness” that “poor whites denigrated as ‘hillbillies’ who were viewed as socially inferior to the incoming immigrant groups” used to communicate their “Americanness” as a form of superior status (Walley, 2013, 36).

         Hence, she finds that Little Grandpa never appeared to “privilege the plight of the working man over such prejudices” (Walley, 2013, 41). This in mind, Walley’s Little Grandpa still took some stances that may be regarded as radical. To preserve the best interests and safety of workers who identified much like himself, Little Grandpa advocated for the steel mill workers’ rights to unionize. In this regard, it appears that Little Grandpa recognized the need for and importance of standing up to exploitative measures put in place by the “big guys.” However, given his ardent opposition to recognizing the unifying “plight of the working man” – an experience that spanned across ethnic “boundaries”, it appears that Little Grandpa’s support of unionization is somewhat contradictory. Hence, when reading this section, I questioned: to form an effective and influential union, wouldn’t you want to unify all workers under a common cause given their common struggles?

    In the proceeding section however, I began to gain some more insight into the disconcerting, yet logical undercurrents of Little Grandpa’s prejudiced outlook. As Walley writes, anti-immigrant sentiments appear to emerge from the mass hiring of newly-arrived immigrants who, as a result of their vulnerable condition and the need to work, could be exploited as a means to break strikes and lower wages of seasoned workers. Moreover, “In an older industrial world, where workers and their families depended upon ethnic ties as their primary social safety net”, leaders would “[encourage] and [exploit] ethnic and racial tensions in a deliberate attempt to keep laborers divided” (Walley, 2013, 41).

    In turn, it seems factory workers like Little Grandpa may be have been subjected to a degree of Marxian “false consciousness”. As explained in the Voice Thread on Marx, false consciousness is the result of a particular class [often working, lower classes] being deluded about the means by which they may fulfill their best interests and in turn, maximize their potential. According to Marx, this false consciousness is often a product of deceptive ideology that is put in place by the bourgeoisie exploiters who seek to maintain and subsequently reap the benefits from this false consciousness. Hence, in the context of Little Grandpa and others like him, it appears that their racial prejudices and aversions toward the “immigrant other”, were exacerbated and in turn, exploited by the industrial leaders as a means to further personal gain.

As suggested by Walley, by hiring mass groups of immigrants to subvert their obligation treating their existing workers properly, the industrial leaders configured newly arriving immigrants as risks to seasoned workers. In turn, the interests and job security of workers such as Little Grandpa could be undermined by new workers. Thus, it appears that in hiring masses of immigrants who would work under any conditions, industrial leaders cultivated a culture of division which in turn, ensured that a unified monolith of workers could never push for and ultimately gain the benefits they sought. Overall, although Walley notes that this phenomenon is characteristic of early industrial factory systems, I argue that this exploitative dynamic can be easy seen in other contemporary contexts – particularly the ways in which Americans respond to the arrival of illegal immigrants.

    In the Trump Era especially, I have observed the emergence of a dominant anti-immigrant rhetoric among poorer working class white Americans who fear that illegal immigrants will take their jobs. Ultimately, in my view this apprehension and aversion appears to be somewhat unwarranted. Given that I have immigrant family members, I have a particular sensitivity toward illegal immigrants and immigrants. According to my understanding, immigrants are crucial contributors to the American economy insofar as they often take jobs that are necessary, yet undesired by American citizens. However, if I draw upon the conditions that inform Little Grandpa’s attitudes towards immigrant “outsiders”, I begin to understand the fear that exists among poorer white working classes as very real and thus, legitimate (hence, there may be a slight issue in referring to their consciousness as ‘false’…). In the context of illegal immigration in particular, illegal status, extreme poverty, and basic need for survival culminates in a commitment to almost any kind of work. Thus, these immigrants may be seen as favorable hires insofar as they can be exploited in atrocious manners that any American, no matter how desperate, would refuse to tolerate.


Comments

  1. Thoughtful response to a complex book and topic--thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. By the way, everyone, this was by Ellen Gunn.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts