Critique on “The Production and Reproduction of Legitimate Language”
* I just wanted to start out by saying that I am by no means a Linguistic anthropologist or would consider myself knowledgeable on this topic at all. However, it was the only article left that had not already been critiqued so here I am.
The article “The Production and Reproduction of Legitimate Language,” written by Bourdieu, addresses the nature of language and the inequalities that exist between the various socioeconomic classes. He starts out by explaining some issues that were present while trying to come up with a legitimate language, which is just the standard language for a given area, like confrontation. However he states that language is “not subject to variation” but differs in “pronunciation, diction, and even grammar.” This difference does not seem too influential but it has been the source of power that has been used over the lower classes through hierarchical styles for centuries. He then goes on to explain how most people, no matter their class, will be understood. However, it isn't likely that the lower classes will be “listened to” or will be deemed “socially acceptable.” This inequality of speaking begins in the upper class. They set the tone and everyone is supposed to follow, even when they are prevented through knowing via “codifications.” There was “training” but they were of course exclusive to certain individuals. So this unbalanced system of literally communicating became a generational issue, with certain “rules” not being known. So from this people clearly felt out of the loop and strived to assimilate to the higher class, and these disparities became very clear and stratigraphic between the classes.
This work was Inspired by Saussure and one can tell because he was a linguistic genius who argued that language is a system of signs that can shape the social structure. He also states that he was inspired by Saussure on page 54. However, Saussure also dealt with the Signifier and the signified. So that can be seen as the upper class has changed various attributes of the signifiers, that would then change the signified to create a clear division and way of keeping their status pure. This may have been a part of the french structuralism movement because it involves analysis of structural relationships between groups.
I think this study and approach are different from others because it is only focusing on the linguistic aspects of this movement, which now seems to be a topic that needs to be addressed because I think you can even see signs of this still happening today. This is what I think is one of the strengths of this article because it allows the reader to draw a contrast with their own environment. Which I feel like is still an issue within the lower class communities due to a lack of funding with educational systems, etc. However, I feel like some of the limitations of this article is that it is a little stale and can be considered too advanced for everyone to read. Which is another thing that I think matters today because I didn't think that the field of anthropology needs to get so formal that it becomes reachable or understandable by the majority because then we are just keeping the information to ourselves.
-Christianestrada99
Comments
Post a Comment