Critique of "The Making of the Maori" - Allan Hanson
BY JACK TALTON
Throughout Allan Hanson’s article “The Making of the Maori” he goes through several instances in which Maori lore and legends such as the “Io cult” and the “Great Fleet” were invented by the people of the time. Part of Hanson’s argument was in relation to the question that even if these large parts of Maori culture were invented and not historically accurate, should we as anthropologists point that out or try and learn and appreciate this invention of culture? Another way to describe the method of the invention of culture is actually mentioned as an example by Hanson on page 890, the Quebecois, used what rhetoricians call constitutive rhetoric in order to create a sense of nationalism in order to try and gain their independence. Although they were not actually their own state/country through the nationalism they inspired and through their work in newspaper articles, this rhetoric made it come alive and seem real. However, what Hanson is saying is different as the Maori people in New Zealand began to express their own “nationalism” and cultural importance by explaining that their practices and rituals cover the faults of the “Paheka” or white people in New Zealand, and that their cultural practices compliment them nicely as to show the importance and significance of their culture.
In the last section of Hanson’s article “The Logic of Cultural Invention” he draws from Derrida and his ideas of “logocentrism” and “metaphysics of presence” and even pulls an excerpt in which Derrida talks about sign-substitutions and when there is a moment when “in the absence of a center or an origin, everything became discourse” which is what happened to the Maori lore and legends in their creation because they could not trace back a starting point. However, does this make their practices, beliefs and cultures any less real, or any less important in terms of what to study or what to practice? This remains the question, but Hanson does say on page 899 that “cultural inventions acquire authenticity in the eyes of members of society” but little do we know as members of society, that even our cultures started somewhere, who’s to say it wasn’t created in the same way?
One last thing to think about in terms of whether these practices, beliefs and legend were constructed by man should be pointed out as wrong because of this absence of origin, is that many practices and cultures we admire in books and in museums were often started in the same way. Even if they didn’t start that way, word of mouth is like a game of telephone, and so before written accounts can we really say we know the real origin of any cultural practice? And if so, does this mean the cultures we have studied and marveled at for years should be disregarded? Clearly the answer is no and from this article, I see that change is necessary and culture is created every day, and as long as cultural practices have significance to someone, who’s to say they aren’t important?
Good translation of Hanson for a general audience! I'm not sure I understand the distinction you are making between the Quebecois and the Maori. Maybe if someone else responds to this post (or if the author circles back), they can explain it a bit more?
ReplyDelete