Critique of "Luck, Friendship, and the Narrative Self"
BY ALLY SWARTZBERG
In his work Luck, Friendship, and the Narrative Self, Mattingly considers the project of becoming that is created through "accidents of fortune." Through the example of a young boy who burns his face with cooking grease, Mattingly aims to highlight the ways in which occurrences of chance can provide a radically altered circumstance which both highlights inadequacies and requires new virtues for individual actors. However, at a deeper level, the narration given here is telling another story; it sheds light on the working-class experience of a single-family. In so doing, Mattingly's work aims to demonstrate the ways in which individuals both define and are themselves defined by the culture in which they live.
Mattingly uses theorists such as Arendt to acknowledge that action necessarily brings on a series of unforeseeable consequences -- some desirable and others less so. But in a deviation from more traditional conceptions of normative behavior, she considers a sort of interpersonal renormalization called moral reorientation. In a somewhat veiled consideration of cultural norms, Mattingly builds the following case: First, he suggests that "to act" is a twofold process. It begins with the individual actor and reaches achievement through cooperation with the choices of other individual actors. Second, she acknowledges the relationship between luck and the process of moral becoming (in the sense defined by virtue ethicists). Third, she contends that the discernment of moral agency relies on cultural resources which consist of mundane routines and material spaces.
So what does this have to do with norms, you may ask. In his fourth contention, Mattingly claims that perception cannot be willed away. That is to say, what plainly exists, rather than being taken in and defined in a vacuum, is considered with the influence of a set of external factors and paradigmatic assumptions. Any attempt to redefine a perception, Mattingly suggests, is a painstaking and conscious process. Oftentimes, it is one that requires another impetus to challenge the actor's preconceived notion. In this work, we thus actually see Mattingly create a microcosmic example of how norms can define individual experiences within a culture, perhaps even in such a hegemonic way that the norms themselves are considered objective reality.
In this work, Mattingly has taken an almost Aristotelian stance on morality and agency -- seeking to define virtue as each individual actor's ability to consider external factors and calibrate action "about the mean". Yet, alongside this nod to traditional virtue ethicism, Mattingly brings Anthropology into the mix, acknowledging the deeply embedded ways in which each actor is defined by an evolving culture which they themselves in part create. This duality comes in step with the post-modernist assertion that all reality is subjective. At the same time, Mattingly challenges conventional ethnography which centers the extraordinary to piece together an erroneously complete picture of some seemingly stagnant culture. This ethnographic tradition is one that post-modernists would challenge. Instead, Mattingly's focus is the mundane. Through treating subjective experiences as the basic floor of culture, Mattingly thus redefines culture as a process of becoming which surrounds actors as a set of resources that help them construct themselves.
So, can an entire culture be adequately studied through individual narrations? Probably not. There are limitations to this practice -- namely because it may create a temptation to define culture only in terms of individuals when, in reality, aggregate phenomena can rarely be defined by a piecemeal addition of their parts. But that is not to say that there isn't value in bringing Anthropological study down to the individual level. There is much to be learned about the aggregate phenomenon that is culture, and individual narratives like this one present an important lens through which hegemonic assumptions can be challenged. It recenters the people and their ordinary actions that define culture, rather than centering only abstract ideas or rituals as they are observed in a highly mechanized way by an outsider.
Thank you for this thoughtful contextualization and analysis! I think Mattingly would say (very much like Stewart) that, though the narratives may be individual, the pieces used to construct them all come from a common stream. Thus, both authors would argue that individual life narratives are a way, perhaps the only way, to study the entire culture. N.B. Mattingly identifies as female.
ReplyDelete