Critique of "From Jibaro to Crack Dealer"
Phillippe Bourgois’ “From Jibaro to Creak Dealer: Confronting
the Restructuring of Capitalism in El Barrio” examines the production and
reproduction of Puerto Ricans’ culture and identity in the context of factory
and service industry jobs. Conducting his ethnographic study in New York City,
Bourgois interviews several people living in East Harlem, often referred to as
“El Barrio” or Spanish Harlem. Bourgois says that he hopes to, “show the
local-level implications of the global-level restructuring of capital and, in
the process, give voice to some unrepentant victims” (Bourgois 1995, 676).
The authors first argues that the past three to four
generations of Puerto Rican people in New York City have passed through six
modes of production. 1.) small landowning, semi-subsistence peasantry, 2.)
export agricultural laborers on foreign capital-intensive plantations, 3.)
factory workers in urban shanty towns, 4.) sweatshop workers in ghetto
tenements, 5.) service-sector employees in high-rise, inner city housing
projects, and 6.) underground economy entrepreneurs homeless on the street. He
claims the Puerto Rican people have gone through so many different modes
because there has been long-term, deep seated racial discrimination against
Puerto Rican migrant workers, causing historic structural transformations to be
imposed on this cultural group. The result is devastatingly high levels of
unemployment, poverty, substance abuse, and health problems within U.S.
mainland, Puerto Rican communities. Within his ethnography Bourgois focuses
specifically on the shift from factory work to service industry jobs, to the underground
economy and how this relates to Puerto Rican cultural identity.
Bourgois says that all of the crack dealers that he
interviewed held one or more legal jobs in their youth; many would drop out of
high school in order to work in factory jobs. These young Puerto Ricans often
found it easy to enter the manufacturing workforce because they received ample
support from their extended families who were well-versed in “working-class
common sense.” Bourgois also says that the desire to drop out of school and
start working in factories demonstrates the cultural subscription to the
working-class ideologies about the dignity of engaging in hard work rather than
pursuing an education. The problem with this system is that these young men entered
the manufacturing workforce during a period of rapid job loss, and once there
were no more factory jobs in the city they found themselves to be unemployable
high school dropouts leaving them in a position of social marginalization and
no where to go other than the lowest level service-industry jobs.
Bourgois goes on to describe how entry level factory jobs were
a much more welcoming environment to the tough and “violently macho” street
culture that many Puerto Ricans developed and cultivated. The presence of
older, more experienced workers who were also high school dropouts boosted the
cultural value of being tough and showing a certain level of opposition to the
foremen in charge is considered appropriately masculine. In sharp contrast is
the cultural environment of the entry level service jobs that Puerto Ricans
were forced into after the majority of factory jobs in the city were lost. In
these jobs people are expected to display humility and obedience within a
workplace hierarchy, use “proper” English, and adhere to white cultural norms.
Anyone that cannot abide by these rules has little to no chance of upward
mobility. Those that remain in the workplace are completely prevented from
expressing their cultural identity and are often mocked and belittled as they
struggle to follow the cultural norms of the white-collar environment, as in
the case of Julio’s boss referring to him as “illiterate” in front of other
employees. On top of this, the unions and fellow workers that allowed
individuals to express cultural autonomy in factory jobs are absent in the
service industry. This means that any attempts to demonstrate resistance and
agency, like when Julio would exaggerate his accent while answering the phones to
combat his boss’s linguistic discrimination, or when he and Willie would steal
office supplies or clock extra hours for overtime, often result in the employee
being fired.
With no cultural autonomy or support, no chance of upward
mobility, and constant exposure to insults and belittlement, many people leave
the service industry, and enter the underground economy of illegal drug sales. Here,
Bourgois argues, Puerto Rican’s are able to publicly display their cultural
identities through the development and cultivation of a “street identity” which
the author defines as “the ideologies that organize ‘common sense’ on the
street” (Bourgois 675). Because of the underground economy’s lack of a formal
“office hierarchy” and the shelter it offers from belittlement and humiliation,
second and third generation Spanish Harlem residents often celebrate their
“decision” to join the underground economy. Their carefully cultivated street
identities are a source of pride, and they provide meaning, career, and level
of ecstasy in spite of a system that accuses them of laziness and
worthlessness.
As a student of Eric Wolf, Bourgois is considered an
important proponent of the Neo-Marxian theory. He was also influenced by the
post-structural and practice theories of Foucault and Bourdieu, respectively. His
Neo-Marxian standing is most readily seen in his emphasis on the historical
context in his ethnography and his criticism of the structural-functionalist
idea that social institutions serve the needs of society as a whole. Bourgois
looks at the history of Puerto Rican immigration and discrimination in the United
States and New York City, and he highlights the fact that many of the institutions
in place (especially the service industry) are in fact detrimental to the
people that he is studying. Bourgois also draws from Foucault and Post Structuralism
in his celebration of “subjugated knowledges”, the ways of understanding the human
experience from people that are not in power. The author states that, “to overcome
such a partial perspective [victim blaming] when researching painful human contexts,
it is especially important to develop a sensitive political economy analysis
that ‘articulates the hidden histories’ of the peoples raking themselves over
the coals of the latest forms of capitalism” (Bourgois 688).
The main strength of Bourgois’s ethnography is how often he integrates the interviews he conducted into his writing. Most of the points he makes are preceded or followed by comments from Julio, Willie, or Julio’s mother. Bourgois incorporates these interviews because they are at the core of his ethnographic data, and he uses them to illustrate the complex social and cultural issues that are woven into the fabric of Spanish Harlem. He is also intentional in vocalizing his concerns about the ethnography, and he acknowledges that, “such an extensive examination of street participants risks exoticizing the neighborhood and may be interpreted as reinforcing violent stereotypes against Puerto Ricans” or that “case studies of the ‘worthy poor’ risk normalizing the experience of class and racial segregation” (Bourgois 675). The weakest point of Bourgois’s ethnography is his Marxian homogenization of populations, and his insistence that there is nothing structurally exceptional about the Puerto Rican experience other than the fact that it is more visible due to “the extent and rapidity with which Puerto Rican society has been absorbed by the United States” (Bourgois 675). This claim that the Puerto Rican experience within the white-dominated cultural environment is no different than any other minority experience downplays Puerto Rican cultural agency, and it could lead to important information being ignored when ethnographies are being conducted.
Josh Milon
Really great synthesis of Bourgois' piece, Josh! Everyone seeking to understand Bourgois should read this.
ReplyDelete