Critique of Clifford Geert'z, "Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight"

 BY: LISETTE VICTORIA SAN PEDRO

    Clifford Geertz introduces himself as an outsider to the Balinese people. Initially, Geertz had yet to establish any rapport which is detrimental to participant observation, which relies on personal relations with cultural informants to develop an emic understanding. Therefore, he demonstrated how he inadvertently gains respect by running away during a police raid of an illegal cockfight. This strengthened his relations with the Balinese because as an outsider he could have stayed to sway the police, placing himself on a moral high ground, or he could have acted as an innocent bystander. However, his actions of placing himself on the same level as others enjoying the cockfight as a cultural pastime, allowed for some level of social acceptance. By way of the Balinese accepting Geertz, he then effectively observes behavior and records data as more than an outsider. Additionally, Geertz supports his observation with prior historical and literary research of Balinese cultural concepts. In order to understand the significance of cocks and cockfighting, he assimilates himself with Balinese association of animals with demons.

    Geertz employs the use of cross-cultural comparison to translate Balinese attitudes on cocks and cockfighting to and American audience. The use of American ideas to simplify Balinese practices, casts a simplistic, ethnocentric Westernized understanding of the Balinese. For example, Geertz likens cockfighting to baseball or poker, which are traditionally marketed as American, masculine past times. At various times, Geertz likens these practices to outwardly masculine ideals, with no understanding of feminine perspectives on cockfighting. Although, Geertz states, that the cockfights are strange occurrences of same sex hobbies, its effects on the community are not limited to men. Through Geertz's failure to observe if women are important in the very fabric of cock fighting, he loses out on understanding its larger significance. 

    Geertz fails to provide a holistic representation of the subject by neglecting to research its symbolism to women within their villages. Without a holistic view, he fails to capture a complete symbolistic understanding of cockfighting. As stated, women are not involved in the direct action of cock fighting, but their indirect support likely affects the attitudes and outcomes of men. Again, his rendering of cockfighting “as symbolic expression of manifestations of their owners self, the narcissistic male ego” entirely restructures what cockfighting means to be palatable to an American audience. When participating in ethnographic work, I feel as though cross-cultural analogies weaken the audience’s understanding of the respective cultures because of unintentional connotations. For instance, the ideas of narcissism and ego reorient the reader into an American mindset and limits one’s possible relativism. Although, Geertz effectively enters himself into the Balinese culture, his lack of female representation surrounding cockfights offers a one sided understanding of its symbolism. Not to mention, his analogies are extremely Americanized and places the cockfights within an American paradigm.

Comments

Popular Posts