Critique of Arjun Appadurai's "Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy"
Arjun Appadurai argues in this paper about how increased rate of cultural exchange through imaginary landscapes, socially constructed arenas in which people pass information to each other. These imaginary overlaps, or 'disjunctures' pass cultural information back and forth between national forces, such as the largest global powers and the tiniest isolated nations, all the way down to the smallest unit of imagined information, the individual. Appadurai mentions five particular disjunctures; ethnoscapes, the physical movement of people and the cultures they bring with them around the world; technoscapes, the "global configuration" of technology and how technology is distributed across the world, granting increased communicative abilities as well as production capabilities; finanscapes, the often unpredictable global movement of financial capital and resources; mediascapes, the capability of technology to disseminate information and create images of the world through that content; and finally ideoscapes, the use of world-images (often generated in a mediascape) to spread ideologies and values, usually for political purposes.
Appadurai provides the example of a number of nations to demonstrate how these disjunctures interact and are valued differently across the world. He cites the welcoming ideoscape of Japan, a nation which also lacks a flowing ethnoscape. Appadurai contrasts this with circum-Mediterranean groups, who allow an exchange of workers and therefore maintain a variable ethnoscape. These shifting ethnoscapes create deterritorialization, the movement of labor populations to other nations and bringing their culture, money, ideas and politics with them. This deterritorialization creates many disjunctures and has been a major force in the shifting of global culture in the modern era. Appadurai continues to provide examples of the relationship between deterritorialization, disjunctures, and nationhood, providing multiple examples; the religious spread of Islam and the political situation in China, how Hollywood both feeds on exoticism and provides cultural material for those far from their birthplace, and even how the spread of certain firearms is an indicator of underlying ethnoscapic shifts. He continues to outline other elements of culture which interact with each other through his shifting disjunctures, such as gender roles and generational knowledge.
Appadurai paints a picture in this article which attempts to reduce the enormous forces of our world into a series of much more palatable (and less overwhelming) concepts. These disjunctures serve this purpose excellently: the various overlaps of the "-scapes" does indeed seem to cover many global forces and factors which impact our daily lives. However, as a limitation, I would suggest that by this reduction of the factors that impact our world, Appadurai may have been slightly too reductionist - perhaps the simple inclusion of a few other disjunctures would have fleshed out the concept more. For example, the forced cultural exchange of information through military opposition often ends in a forced way of political living without an actual change in the ideoscape or opinions of the subjugated people. Only the way the nation is run changes, and largely in part due to the threat of a far-off nation. Thus it is not quite a shift in either the ethnoscape or the ideoscape, but rather some other kind of disjuncture involving physical power. This and others may fill out a few global factors which some could consider to be lacked in this theory. That being said, I do think Appadurai crafted a well-constructed theory of these disjunctures, and I agree with the idea of all of the different disjunctures given: He provides numerous examples from global perspectives which truly reveal the extent to which we interact with the disjunctures of cultural information as members of our global society.
-RJ Pratt
Word Count: 587
Thanks for this helpful overview of the five -scapes, RJ!
ReplyDelete