Critique: Mattingly’s “Luck, Friendship, and the Narrative Self”

By Haley Smith


What was most striking about Mattingly’s work was her framing of the moral transformation process as a communal experience. Instead of understanding “moral transformation” as a short-term individual process, Mattingly gives us an ethnographic example that shows how friends and family are inherent actors in the drawn-out journey of moral development. Instead of drawing ethnographic data from a conglomerate of field stories (as we have seen with Boasian anthropology), she hones in on one family’s story of moral becoming to illustrate the interpersonal nature of moral development. From a theoretical standpoint, Mattingly draws on Boas’s particularism to illustrate a more Durkheim conclusion about “project[s] of moral becoming” (742). In other words, we see an analysis of communal moral becoming as a social fact from a “particular” example. This reminds us that the discipline of anthropology is determined by the anthropologists themselves, and is not an abstract entity that exists outside of the anthropologist to which they must replicate.

In this piece, Mattingly introduces the reader to an African American family whose son’s face was burned by oil at a young age. The narrative is initially centered around the son’s mother, Sasha, who must undergo a moral re-orientation to best raise a son under these new circumstances. Mattingly writes, “Such events not only expose inadequacies that were once unnoticed, they demand virtues not needed before. Accidents create new situations that demand new or more well-developed virtues in order to even perceive a ‘best good’ in uncharted waters” (741). Self-reflection is central to this process and does not happen in isolation. The reader rather sees moral becoming as a negotiation between Sasha and her mother, Delores. Delores pushes back on many of Sasha’s reactions to her son’s facial burns. Both Sasha and Delores engage in a collective mothering of Willy that eventually allows their household to undergo a moral transformation. This raises the question: Can an individual (let’s say Sasha) undergo moral reorientation without their larger community (her family) being affected? Mattingly argues no. Additionally, it is interesting to consider spatial proximity. Does increased spatial proximity (in this case, living in the same household) positively correlate with how much one's community is affected by moral re-orientation? 

While story-telling is the central data to this piece, it is also central to the family’s moral journey. Stories play a critical role in forming identities. Just as moral becoming “is a slow journey informed by those around you”, understandings of the self are equally informed by the ways people talk about you (742). Sasha “consistently identifies her son as a gifted boy and a family healer who is somehow above the fray” while Delores “actively creates a different child, one who is ‘ordinary’” (752). Willy’s self-perception is arguably affected by how the two women treat and talk about him. I would have liked Mattingly to dive deeper into this, as I feel Willy was a side character in his own story.


Comments

  1. Great job of addressing Mattingly's emphasis on the collective and narrative natures of identity and moral becoming, Haley. Thank you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You also captured the accidental or random aspect of lived reality as portrayed by M.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts