Applying White to Sustainable Development
Within his article “Energy and the Evolution of Culture,” Leslie White argues that social progress is driven by harnessing more energy. He attempts to show that society has gained complexity and power as we have controlled a greater amount of energy. Social progress can be linked directly back to energy consumption. White points to major events, such as the Agricultural Revolution and Industrial Revolution, to show the ways that greater energy harnessed was also closely linked to large ideological and social changes. He created a formula, E x T = P, where E is the amount of energy expended per capita per unit of time, T is the technological means, and P is the overall result. Thus, progress is a function of energy harnessed and technology innovation. He argues that societal progress is unilinear but not inevitable; rather, it comes as a direct result of greater energy use. However, White believes that human agents do not necessarily know what they are doing in regard to creating change. Thus, culture that does not go through clear stages may become stagnant for long periods of time if the energy and technology remain consistent. He points toward the long period of feudalism as a time where innovation did not occur; thus, human societies did not necessarily change or become more complex during that time.
I think that White would have a very interesting take on current climate change discourses. I think that he would be really concerned about the argument that humans should lessen their consumption overall, including energy. Under his model of culture, he believes that culture stagnates or even regresses when energy consumption changes. White believes that energy reduction inherently leads to cultural degradation, and so he would be really against these ideas. Thus, he would not want to reduce overall energy consumption because it would cause our culture to decline.
However, I can see him fighting for technological advancement as a potential solution for climate change. Within his equation, increased technology can compensate for the reduction of energy consumption as a whole.
One way to compensate for less energy usage would be increased technological usage. He would probably advocate for increased technology to make up for the reduction of raw energy. White would not mind a reduction in consumption as long as technology makes up for the efficiency. I could imagine him investing in engineering and other research in order to make sure that we do not regress as a society.
At the end of the day, I think that White would actually be against many climate change solutions because he would be on the side of energy companies. He definitely believes that more is better, and I don’t actually think he would actually advocate for even a temporary reduction of energy. He seems to be extremely concerned with the progression of human culture, and I am inclined to think that he would argue for a greater use of available resources.
As climate change and environmental justice debates heat up, so do discussions of sustainable development. Scientists are looking for solutions to our climate problem. Many people don’t want a reduction of their quality of life, and many others are seeking an improvement. They want to continue to live ‘well,’ even at the cost of the environment. Arguably, consumption (and over consumption) are some of the most concerning parts of individual environmental impact. This is not even thinking about massive industrial waste created by top companies who have not been held responsible for their emissions and waste production. Fossil fuel use is allowing humankind to advance in society, but it is also harming our long-term future because of climate change. As humanity advances technologically, we become more and more dependent on energy that is mostly generated by fossil fuels. We need to be mindful of the ways that we utilize the energy available to us, especially as it continues to have adverse effects on our world.
Meilyn
Comments
Post a Comment