Appadurai's Technoscape and Gift-Giving Societies
The technoscape Appadurai explains in his article "Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy" may be the most dynamic of the factors creating the disjunctures of the global cultural economy. In the last two decades, the technoscape has shifted dramatically and taken a central position in how much of the world runs on a day-to-day basis. We send messages instantly across the world sharing our thoughts and feelings. We transfer vast digital funds with the press of a button. A quick look on Google Images provides access to our most valued art, our music through Spotify or Apple Music, our films and amateur recordings of the ordinary on Netflix and YouTube. The internet is, for all intents and purposes, not only a cultural database but a staging ground. We store, create, and transmit cultural data through the digital landscape. But this cultural arena has been far too impactful to only receive and transfer culture. It has increasingly had an impact on our culture outside of the internet. The rise of memes as forms of comedy and communication in everyday life is a fine example of this. But how has it impacted our lives in other ways?
Marcel Mauss posited that gift-giving in society serves more than an economic function. It can create and strengthen social bonds between individuals and communities. An act of gift giving can carry ritual or symbolic significance. And with the disjunctures provided by the ever-expanding technoscape, the act of gift-giving has begun to see the shift in the global cultural economy as well.
Every day, I open Instagram and see that it is somebody's birthday. Usually I don't get that information from the person who is celebrating's account (with the exception of people of a certain self-involvement): rather, I get the information from their close friends or family, who have created a "story", a digital monument to the celebratee which rises and falls in a 24 hour period, sometimes reposted to the person's own story. If someone is VERY important to another and celebrating a birthday, they might get a whole post devoted to them, which remains on the celebrator's page as a much more permanent signifier of their friendship. This has become a tradition to many since Instagram first became popular. The birthday has been a tradition in many parts of the world for thousands of years - but this digitization is quite new. It is also a perfect example of the digitization of gift-giving. In the past, one may have gone to see their friends to celebrate a birthday. Then came the phone calls. Now are these posts online. This is not to say that those other ways are gone (in fact they are largely alive and well), but rather that a whole new form of gift-giving has been birthed by way of the technoscape, and one which carries a much more widespread social impact than the others. By posting online, the gift-giver publicly consummates their friendship, and it is fully expected that when the gift-giver's birthday comes around, a post of equal value will also be published. It is a cultural exchange of public friendship, making it hold a different place in society than the more private personal wishes of "happy birthday to you!" sung around a cake in a dark room.
Another example I can think of is something my friends and I have come to call, through a series of bad puns, the Ven-diagram. When we go out to eat the cheap food so often purchased by college-age students, the person in the front of the car, on the side of the drive through window usually pays everyone's meal with their card. Then everyone else immediately pays them for their meal through Venmo, an app which allows you to make personal payments from a virtual bank. But, we all end up switching who is sitting in the pay seat to keep things even. Therefore, we have developed a small pool of digital currency, which we trade back and forth to each other, and seems to never actually get spent. "Time to send the same seven dollars we just send back and forth every semester", one of my friends joked at the start of the Spring semester. These digital dollars have essentially been removed from circulation, making them have no economic value, for all intents and purposes. But they do serve the symbolic purpose of gift-giving: a show of goodwill and the intention to show you have the backing for your friend's purchase.
These are the two main examples I came up with, but I am certain there are many more instances of gift giving being developed across the technoscape which have impacts on Appadurai's various disjunctures, both at the individual and global levels. If you can think of any, feel free to respond to this post with one - I'd love to hear others' opinions and instances of digital gift-giving.
-RJ Pratt
Word Count: 818
Your analysis of the closed circulation of currency within your friend group is really insightful, as is the connection you draw between Appadurai and Mauss. Thank you!
ReplyDelete