THE BODY ISSUE AND IT'S BOUNDARIES

  THE BODY ISSUE AND IT'S BOUNDARIES

By: Emily Conway

 For about 11 years, EPSN has come out with a BODY Issue in which they do a photo shoot and interview with athletes. What makes this Issue different from all other ESPN issues and most other magazine interviews is that the athletes are completely naked. The purpose of the BODY Issue is “to celebrate the incredible power of the athletic form.” Each year features athletes from an array of sports and disciplines. It all started in 2009 with a group of 20 athletes and has superspeed everything people thought it would be. Some athletes that have been featured include Olympic skier Gus Kenworthy, speed skater Apolo Ohno, NFL player Odell Beckhan Jr, Soccer players Sur Bird and Megan Rapinoe. The Issue itself has broken many barriers and portrayed athletes in their truest form, and the stories associated with the images are equally as impressive. In 2016 transgender duathlete Chris Mosier shared his transitioning story and how that affected his sense of himself and his body. Overall, the BODY issue has inspired a deeper appreciation for the athletic form, and all that comes with those athletes. 

    If bodily boundaries are metaphors for the boundaries of society, as Douglas suggests, the BODY issue is a pushing of societal boundaries. Therefore, it runs the risk or danger of pushing the margins of those bodily boundaries, which represent the breaking of societal boundaries. Douglas identifies the dangers as social pollutants, which are broken into four categories: Danger of pressing on external boundaries; Danger from transgressing internal lines of a system; Danger in margins of the lines and; Danger from internal contradictions. Overall, these dangers are marked in different ways based on the society or those “rules” associated with the culture. The societal boundaries that are symbolically being pushed in this case are not truly detrimental to the stability of the society. And it is not pollution because it is a positive framework to consider nudity - not toxic. In considering Douglas’s interpretation of purity, I would argue that looking at the body in this way is valuing purity. While the nude is usually considered or viewed as an impure state, this is framing it as a good thing. In most cases, nudity is frowned upon because it is hyper-sexualized.  What makes this such a different article is that it is naked but not in a sexualizing manner. Unlike sports illustrated swimsuit issues, the nakedness is to exemplify the athletic strength and power of people that excel in their perspective sport.

    To be honest, I think this is a very bold stance and breaks a lot of social norms, especially for women. And I LOVE it. Within the United States, there are standards of what physically is allowed to be shown in society but more so what is NOT allowed to be exposed. I think back to the high school dress code in which girls would get in trouble for showing their bra straps or shoulders. Or how in middle school, I wore my lacrosse jersey (which was the standard protocol on game day) to school and got in trouble because it scooped too low on my side and showed my sports bra. Ultimately there really is a complicated relationship between the body and what is to be shown that is obviously challenged in the BODY Issue.

   Is it controversial? Yes.  Does it break social norms? Yes. Is it polluting to society? No.

    I would argue that pushing bodily boundaries like in this case does not represent a dangerous act or social polluting but rather an expansion of social boundaries for the reason that it doesn't sexualize the naked body but celebrates it.The body can be most definitely be used as or stand for the bounded system in society. But the body is also an incredibly personal thing. For these athletics, their body is the literal representation of their success, hardships, struggles, and careers in the same way that a doctor’s brain and scope of knowledge are. Essentially showing off Chris Paul’s body is synonymous with taking a picture of Dale Earnhardt’s car. They are the vehicles that provide athletes their success. The BODY Issue website classifies itself as a “cultural force,” which is most definitely true. 


here is the link to the website: https://www.espn.com/espn/feature/story/_/id/27400369/the-body-issue#!

Comments

  1. Hi, Emily,

    I really love your discussion on the ESPN “The Body Issue” photoshoot and your argument on “pushing bodily boundaries like in this case does not represent a dangerous act or social polluting but rather an expansion of social boundaries for the reason that it doesn't sexualize the naked body but celebrates it”. I was not responsible for Douglas’ “External Boundaries” in our class but I was fascinated by the idea of “bodily boundaries are metaphors for the boundaries of society” and “the BODY issue is a pushing of societal boundaries”. While reading your post, I was inspired to think about what is the relationship between human bodies and social norms or cultures in a society. It quickly reminds me of a research I did back then on corset. As we all know, during the Victorian era, women, especially those from upper and middle classes were encouraged to wear corsets to modify their bodies to cater with the social expectation back then. This tortuous body modification reflects the social norm in Victorian society that women were restricted in rights to their bodies and economies and were expected to be the “household angel”. So the women with “14-inch waist” is a metaphor of the restricted social norms and cultures of the Victorian period. Those who did not wear corset, usually came from the lower class in the society because they could not afford corsets, were not necessarily considered as “impure”, but definitely not encouraged and well-respected during that era. Later during WWII, women got rid of corsets because they were bestowed with more responsibilities to be able to work and support the military. Compared to the Victorian era, the relief from corsets shows a certain level of women emancipation, even though gender inequality still exists. Today, corset has its meaning completely shifted from a sign of oppression to an art project. Many women choose to wear corsets not out of the purpose to modify the body but rather as an accessory. From this shift, it really shows the development of women rights and gender equality. Even though today many women still choose to modify their bodies to achieve social expectation through cosmetic surgeries, diets or medicine and people who do not fit in social expectation usually become the victim of bully or body shame, there’s still more tolerance and freedom in female bodies compared to the Victorian era. To summarize, the relief from corsets, the relief from restricted body modification or this extension of body boundaries really demonstrates the constant pushing and extending of social boundaries in women’s rights and gender equality, just like how the athletic nuded body is celebrated by its positivity today (instead of seeing it as hyper-sexualized before).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Another really interesting example! I'm wondering what Leacock and other Marxian feminists, or even the post-structuralists, would say about corsets!?

      Delete
  2. Very creative post, with a great summary along the way. Your case presents a challenge to Douglas, but also reaffirms the centrality of the body as a symbolic nexus for cultural expression and a working out of the social order (whatever that may look like in a particular society).

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts