The Balinese Cockfight: A Ritual of Rebellion?
BY ELLEN GUNN
In Geertz’s “Deep play: notes on the Balinese cockfight”, he interprets the cockfight as a dramatic expression of “status concerns” in Balinese society (Geertz, 1973). As a result, I find that the cockfight may be understood as a ritual of violence or rebellion. Drawing upon existing or potential social tensions, these rituals create a liminal space in which these tensions may be released and in turn, the social order or appropriate social behavior may be reinforced. Thinking back to the Myth, Ritual and Symbolism course I took a few years back, we entertained the medieval carnival as such an avenue.
During the carnival, an event that the nobles hold for the people, the dissipated social order and the symbolic potential for social mobility is conveyed through exaggerated performances and role reversals. The upper class joins the lower class and the lower class may perform upper class characters. In turn, the carnival is space condones and embraces unaccepted behavior; interclass tensions are released so that after carnival, social order may be re-established. Ultimately, although Geertz indicates that the social hierarchy in the Balinese cockfight system is quite rigid – those who may partake in the large cockfights and central bets are principally dominant male authority figures—I find that a degree of social ambiguity comes into play in practice via the avenues of taboo animalistic behavior and the strictly symbolic nature of status mobility.
As Geertz observes, the cockfights allow for a dramatic spectacle of extremity and violence. Ultimately, Geertz understands the relationship of the cock owner and the cock to not only serve as a medium for the expression of masculinity, but also animality – a quality that Balinese culture expresses an aversion to due to the fear of the destructive and consuming capacities of demonic powers. As symbolic representations yielding distinct forms of power, the former creative and the latter destructive, what results is a dramatic synthesis of “hatred, cruelty, violence, and death” (Geertz, 1973) This is expressed most clearly in the tearing apart of the losing cock’s body, which is then handed off to the winner to eat in a “mixture of social embarrassment, moral satisfaction, aesthetic disgust”.
In the article, Geertz refers to such behavior as an expression of the id insofar as the cockfight ritual allows for indulgence in violent, primitive and cannibalistic behavior. In turn, I argue that perhaps the cockfight is a ritual that allows for the expression and release of actions that in ordinary context are not to be entertained – especially not by dominant figures in the social hierarchy. In turn, much like carnival allows for a momentary release and then return to the ordinary social existence, the violence expressed through engagement with the cocks allows for the sustenance of acceptable social functioning and order outside of the fights.
In addition to the symbolic relationship between owners and their cocks, the spectacle of the fights are fueled by aspects of entertainment such as escalating insult exchanges between the owners of opponents. An audience of mutual acquaintances fuels into the level of drama, as does the deep play bet, or a bet “in which the stakes are so high that it is, from his utilitarian standpoint, irrational for men to engage in it at all” (Geertz, 1973). The high stake of the deep play bet ensures that the levels of loss are so significant that when one engages in the high draw, the representation of the bettor’s “public self” is at stake through the cock.
This in mind, over time the bets in larger matches actually even out given the regular pool of participants, which indicates that the cockfight events are first and foremost performative expressions of status power. Hence, the cockfight deep play betting offers a symbolic expression status mobility and in turn, an expression of power tensions between dominant males (in large bets). As a result, sites of potential conflict between figures of the same social strata (i.e. leaders of nearby villages for example) may be mitigated through the medium of ritual expression, which in turn, could possibly sustain mutual respect or smooth social relations between leaders and even their respective groups.
Careful, sensitive, thoughtful, well-written. Thank you!
ReplyDelete