Social-cultural critiques: stereotype of masculinity and femininity
Ruohan Li
Recently, “A Bill concerning the prevention of teenage boys from feminization” has led to an explosive debate on social media around the topic of definition of masculinity as well as the phenomenon of “male feminization” in China. This bill discusses several reasons behind the rising phenomenon of feminization of teenage boys. And I think these hidden reasons should be understood through the theory of agency (traditional cultural and social discourses as well as international influences) from Kwiatkowski’s “Feminist Anthropology”. The proposer of the bill believes that feminization of teenage boys derives from a living and educational environment that contains too much female interactions. When a child is born, he spends most of his time being taken care of by his mother or grandmother. When he enters school, he is surrounded by mostly female teachers. Because of the close interaction with caretakers who are mostly female, boys are easily influenced or spoiled by them, thus becoming delicate, sensitive and cowardly. Applying Kwiatkowski’s discussion on how Confucianism influences Vietnamese women, China is the country that Confucianism originated from, thus in thousands of years of feudalism history, Confucianism dominated the Chinese social norms and created social rules. Very similar to Vietnamese family settings, Chinese families were traditionally set up as males going out to work and supporting families while females were expected to take care of the household and rear children. Even though today’s Chinese society has been completely different from feudal society that women had to be submissive, devoted, and willing to sacrifice for husbands and children (in some Chinese families, women earn more money while men are mainly responsible for taking care of children), still women take most of the caretaker roles in the society. Therefore, this traditional cultural discourse makes this bill look even more ironic as many people commented that men left most of the responsibilities to women to take care of children (instead of being a responsible father) but right now blames women for bringing bad influences to children by turning them feminine. Another reason the proposer provides to explain the phenomenon of femininity is international and social media influences. Due to the influence of Kpop idols, “pretty boy” influencers, and pop stars, many teenage boys follow the popular trend by paying more attention to skincare, makeup, and fashion. The proposer views this trend as problematic as male youths are less interested in becoming heroes and soldiers that could protect the country. I see this argument very problematic because as long as the person has positive and righteous characters, it really doesn’t matter if the person loves doing makeup or working out in the gym more. And as Margaret Mead claimed that differences between men and women result from culture instead of biology, therefore, today’s cultural norms really allow the diversity of various kinds of personality. As the definition of gender has changed constantly along with the cultural shift, today, people’s personality should not be restricted by purely masculine or feminine. So instead of continually stereotyping men and women and restricting them into their own biological stereotypical features, there should be more tolerance on diversity and more discussion on what are the correct definitions of masculinity and femininity.
Right after the publication of the controversial bill, Chinese Education Board showed the opposite opinion and responded that they are going to increase the number of gym classes at schools and focus on the physical and mental strength of both male and female students. This response demonstrates a perspective of unifying masculinity and femininity in some way that both male and female youths should develop a positive character. Being strong, responsible and independent are no longer male-specialized; and being sentimental, patient and empathetic should no longer be female-specialized.
I believe the discussion on masculinity and femininity does not happen in China only but in different regions of the world. How to define masculinity and femininity under today’s global environment? How do we reconcile with current social norms and traditional cultural discourse? How would the gender role change and development in the future? I think there are lots of questions that need to be answered.
Dear Rouhan,
ReplyDeleteThank you for this very interesting post that explains how traditional and progressive understandings and applications of gender are clashing in China. I found your perspective and insights really enlightening, as I am not too familiar with the social aspects of this part of the globe. Similar to Kwiatkowski’s analysis of gender and domestic violence in Northern Viêt Nam, you discuss how the prevailing influence of Confucianism has informed gender-based social structures, roles and behavior in China. In regard to the bill you discussed, what specifically does it propose to do about the “feminization” of males?
I think it is interesting to consider the relationship between law and cultural norms, which shape, inform and engage one another. In Kwiatkowski’s article, she explains that there is “an intersection of revived historical Confucian ideologies of femininity, and contemporary state and global discourses of gender equality and women’s rights…” (242). The state supports both women’s agency (especially in the face of domestic violence) as well as their traditional “place” in the home and the family. The support of both female autonomy and traditional domestic roles (rooted in Confucian thought) is contradictory. Legally speaking, domestic violence is a violation of the law and there are services available to battered Vietnamese women to recieve help. However, culturally speaking, divorce is roughly out of the question as women are expected to preserve their family, which is understood as an essential unit to Vietnamese society. In the case of the bill you discuss, we once again see culture and law responding to one another. In the case of China’s bill against the feminization of men, we see law borne as a form of cultural push back. In the case of Viêt Nam, global cultural institutions led to the creation of the anti-domestic violence law. However, this law is not necessarily effective. It is not effective for two reasons. First, similar to China, Confucian virtues remain highly influential, informing gender roles and social structure. Kwiatkowski writes, “Through the Confucian ‘four virtues’ prescribed for women, they were taught to be hardworking, neat and humble in appearance, soft-spoken and self-controlled in their speech, and filial, loyal, kind, and trustworthy in their behavior” (241). A state can proclaim and advocate legislatively for female agency; however, without the presence of a cultural shift in thinking and behaving, it is unlikely to alter traditional behavior. Second, the law operates in the public domain, while domestic violence is largely private by nature.
Coming back to your socio-cultural example, in what ways has the public nature of male femininity (Kpop, social media exposure) caused shifts in China’s private domains (the home, the family)?
- Haley Smith
Ruohan,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your deeply insightful take on gendered social norms, agency, and their interplay with legal systems. Your reflection drew my attention toward Wolf's concept of structural power. In his work, Wolf identifies this fourth type of power as that which "... operates within settings... [and] also orchestrates and operates the settings themselves." Foucault would have called this "governance" -- and I think this mode of power at least in part embodies the power dynamics at play in the example you have provided, Ruohan. Essentially, the gender norms of China that you have outlined here -- the structure within which enculturation occurs -- is defined by a coercive power which dictates spheres of appropriate work. And yet, that very setting that defines human interactions is itself recreated by each individual interaction, and this is now leading to an interest clash which is demonstrated by the proposed legislation. In order to reify masculinity, men must be kept tough, strong, and in roles like military service, tradesmanship, or those which are otherwise "productive". In this effort, women then take on the caregiver roles -- they are mothers, homemakers, nurses, and teachers. But in strengthening this normative structural power, the young men are inherently more likely to be cared for and raised by women -- and this is deemed to be the source of the "problem" that is feminization. It's almost like a doubling down; gendered roles have created a "problem" which is only a "problem" within an extremely gendered worldview, and the proposed solution for the "problem" is enshrining in legal practice the gender norms which are being challenged, but in that enshrinement, the norms which created this "problem" would be reinforced. Essentially, reinforcing the norm through legislation proscribing "femininity" in men is the automatic assumption because it is so embedded in society despite the structural power (the state) undermining its own claimed interest.
This circular tendency brings me to one main question: How can structural power in the coming years challenge itself to reorder gendered expectations in Chinese society? In other words, how is the power operating within this setting able to organize and reorganize the setting itself?
This is a fascinating case that could be looked at through the lens of so many of our theoretical approaches. Marxian and poststructuralist critiques especially jump out. Drawing on our reading for the week of April 26, one could also explore this from a phenomenological angle. Thank you for sharing this!
ReplyDelete