Social-Cultural Critique: Symbolism of Internet Memes and Their Role as an Online Ritual

    If you have spent any time on social media platforms within the last two decades, you have undoubtedly come across an internet meme; more commonly referred to simply as a “meme.” Memes take countless different forms and can be about any topic you can think of, but in general a meme is an amusing, interesting, and/or relatable piece of media (e.g., image macro, gif, video, etc...) that is widely spread through the internet, especially on social media (Twitter, Instagram, Reddit, etc…). Memes are both an example of symbols in post-industrial societies and a type of ritual that countless people take part in every day. Memes are symbols in many senses: they hold surplus signification power that can transmit meaning to diverse, even conflicting, groups in society. They are also polyvalent signs: a single meme, which is itself an individual unit of meaning, can be a composition of several other memes, which each bring their own unique meaning, and mesh together to form a new meaning that can be different depending on the context and the knowledge of the person who is viewing it. Additionally, the meaning behind memes is shared and public. For example, what does the meme shown below mean to you? 

    Without the knowledge of several different memes (functioning as signs) which have been shared through the internet over time, it probably seems nonsensical. However, every individual image is a signifier for the meaning of each separate picture (the signified), and so there is a very concrete meaning associated with this image. All of the composite parts come from popular media like movies and tv shows, but no single person constructed the meaning of these memes. Rather, meaning was formed through positive and negative feedback throughout the internet in which some memes succeed and become popular while others fail and fade to obscurity: this all depends on the public’s reception of any given format and so the meaning behind memes is shared and public, not psychological and individual. (Unfortunately, the collective meaning of this meme isn’t given justice through the explanation of each individual part, and a rather lengthy explanation would be needed to actually construct this meme’s true meaning, which is beyond the scope of this blog post.) Memes can take feelings and ideas that are difficult to express verbally and make them easily understandable and accessible to just about anyone: not all memes are as cryptic to the inexperienced as the one pictured above. In fact, this meme was originally created to express how many memes can be mashed together into a kind of Frankenstein’s monster meme and still make sense. The main joke was that this image would appear on a history test in the distant future and would ask the students to write an essay describing the meme’s meaning.

    As well as being symbols, the act of sharing and creating memes online can be seen as an informal ritual that millions of people participate in every single day. A ritual is a repetitive and symbolic enactment of a cultural belief or value. While the sharing of memes is more informal than what one would generally consider a ritual, it is still repetitive and symbolizes a wider cultural belief or value. While the above meme is just meant to be amusing, many other memes exist as critiques or commendations of social institutions, popular cultural icons, groups of people or individuals, movements, etc. Countless people from across the world contribute to the collective creation and sharing of memes throughout various platforms on the internet, which exists as a ritual that anyone with internet access can contribute meaning to. Max Gluckman used the term rituals of rebellion, and I think a great deal of memes fall into this category. They exist as an outlet for expression where people can voice their opinions about any given entity or event in creative ways that would not be found in formal avenues of discourse such as academic conferences or news publications. Even further, other memes can be layered so deeply with irony that they become absurd, in the same vein as postmodern art, but even completely absurd memes hold cultural meaning. For example, the image shown below probably appears to be (and also is) completely ridiculous, yet its true meaning (which can be found behind many layers of irony) is meant to mock Mark Zuckerberg during his congressional hearing regarding data privacy. It is these types of memes that especially embody the ritual of rebellion, as they represent an outlet where a person does not need to conform to societal norms of speech and imagery when making a statement about something. These “absurdism memes” function as a channel for people to disregard regular social conditions like standardized speech and coherent images, and basically let loose with nonsensical media instead of conforming to the status quo of acceptable discourse. Thus, memes allow people to blow off steam in a constructive and socially acceptable way rather than in other avenues where such tomfoolery would be frowned upon.

Comments

  1. Such an interesting post, Mitch. I believe that the meme demonstrates that, in the postmodern era, symbols have become highly localized to specific microcultures, political groups, or microgenerations. Because of my age, I don't really "get" the images you've shared. Unlike the central symbols of the Ndembu, these symbols and their circulation mostly serve to further fragment our culture. Would you agree?

    ReplyDelete

  2. Mitch, I truly never considered a meme in a theoretical sense. I love the memes you put into this critique; the visualization added to your argument so well. I like how you specifically considered memes as symbols and informal rituals. I would add to your argument by considering the subgroup of internet culture that memes belong to, known as meme culture. After reading your critique, I wanted to examine the age gap associated with meme culture.

    As you pointed out, the irony and absurdity of some memes contribute to the niche nature of the culture. Memes are a generational phenomenon. The main component that makes memes so culturally important is their ability to separate generations by satire. Satirical irony and absurdity are not new things. For years Saturday Night Live has been mocking pop culture through a very niche form of humor. However, as you pointed out, what makes memes so different is their global reach. As you said, "countless people from across the world contribute to the collective creation and sharing of memes throughout various platforms on the internet, which exists as a ritual that anyone with internet access can contribute meaning to." Memes have an international reach. The new form of language that is constructed within meme culture is the biggest contributor to the generational gap. Because memes are polyvalent signs, not all generations contribute to memes in the same manner. Dr. Bender alluded to this in her comment, but memes serve to fragment culture into more subgroups that are typically generationally tied. Consider vine. The platform has been inactive for years, but references to specific vines are still relevant to our generation's pop culture. Like memes, these vine references are symbolic of a shared experience within a generation that continue to hold an importance.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts