Social-Cultural Critique: The Symbolism of Light

BY ALLY SWARTZBERG

  In "Symbols in Ndembu Ritual", Turner identifies symbols as the smallest units of ritual behavior which still retain the ritual's properties.  There are three key properties of symbols: condensation, unification of disparate significata, and polarization of meaning. Condensation refers to the way in which many meanings and representations are contained within a single symbol. Unification of disparate significata describes the interconnectedness of the symbolic referents which are often connected trivially or through random links of general analogy.  Polarization of meaning is the distinctive way in which "disparate significata", the symbols many referents, become grouped into two clearly distinguishable clusters. Turner identifies the first of the two polar clusters as "ideological", relating to the moral, normative, and value-based referents of a symbol and the second as "sensory", relating to the physical and natural referents.

  Having just participated in Passover and Easter rituals, I have been considering the pervasive symbolism of light in both Christian and Jewish cultures.  While I focus on Jewish rituals, because Christianity grew out of Judaism, many of these ritual meanings carry over.  For context, my dad's family is Jewish (religiously and ethnically) while my mom's family is Christian. I identify with both cultural backgrounds, and the concept of light has always fascinated me. What I noticed, and what I aim to outline below, is the very physical ritual meaning of light as a symbol for warmth, brightness, and shelter (the sensory pole) juxtaposed with the much more value based understanding of light as a symbol for strength, courage, welcoming/hospitality, and the divine (the ideological pole).  This seems at first glance like a fairly clear representation of Turner's understanding of symbols: meanings are condensed in one symbol, the meanings are variant, and the meaning cluster around two poles.  But what I think is worth delving into is the contradictory nature of gender norms which are unconsciously embodied within the single symbol of light.

  In jewish culture, light symbolizes God. According to Jewish teaching, this is because light itself cannot be seen. Rather, it becomes known because its presence enables us to see other things. Similarly, so the teaching goes, while God cannot be seen, His presence becomes known through the goodness in others and the beauty of the natural world. I emphasize here the male pronoun for God, because it is almost universally accepted that God holds a "male" role -- the "Our Father" and the tradition of Rabbis and Priests show us this in tangible ways.  But the way in which light is most commonly introduced into ritual practice today is through the lighting of candles.  When this is done, for Passover or on Sabbath or during Hannukah, it is the woman's role to light the match and pray the blessing over the candles.  Traditionally, this is done for three reasons: first, because the woman runs the home, second, as atonement for Eve's betrayal in the Garden of Eden, and third, because the woman is responsible for the spirituality of the home.

  I argue here that light, which symbolizes a great deal, embodies Turner's key findings while also holding within itself an implicit understanding of the broader culture's expectations for men and women. Women have historically been expected to take up the roles of mother, homemaker, and caregiver.  We are thought of as the warmth and comfort of light.  Men, on the other hand, have taken on the roles of breadwinner, authority, and protector.  They are thought of as the strength and courage of light.  The kind of light that burns.  This is a simplification of the complexity of gender roles, and this particular Jewish practice as it exists today is not a relegation to an undesirable role, the woman's responsibility to light and bless candles is highly valued in Jewish culture, but there are absolutely expectations for women built into this single task.  It implies a position within the household, and the maleness associated with divine light implies a sort of male dominance which is controlled and nurtured by motherhood and womankind.  

  While today gender roles are more balanced, the time in which these rituals began was far less equal.  In a way, maleness is the light which femaleness is meant to bless and protect. Thus, the implicit dominance of men in the broader culture is both reinforced by its likening to God Himself and also challenged by women's power over the light; male strength is subject to female blessing and nurturing. In spite of the modern disdain for such a gendered mindset, this in many ways refers back to Turner's characterization of ritual symbols as embracing the contradictions of the culture. Despite relegation to roles within the home and dependence on men for survival (ie women being unable to have jobs), is there not power in blessing the light, if the light itself is meant to be the source of strength and holiness? After all, the light could not exist if the woman did not light the match.

  

Comments

  1. Beautiful job of symbolic analysis (you would make a good symbolic anthropologist) with important contextualization in social structure and a history of inequality.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It also made me think about how the winter holidays get all the attention for being the celebration of light via the winter solstice. But the spring equinox is equally important, and the light is still growing!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts