Social-cultural critique: “The Making of Maori” and “The Ecological Indian”
By Ruohan Li
In the article “The Making of Maori: Cultural Invention and Its Logic”, Allan Hanson discusses two distinct forms of cultural invention that Maoris had gone through. One form of cultural invention was created by Europeans at the turn of the 20th century for a purpose of better colonizing and assimilating Maori people, while the other form of cultural invention was led by Maoris themselves today in order to maintain their cultural distinctiveness as well as political sovereignty in the society. The two distinct forms seem to be quite contradictory because of the opposite purposes behind their emergence, however, at the same time they are closely connected to each other and both demonstrate how “tradition is now understood quite literally to be an invention designed to serve contemporary purposes” (McGee & Warms, 529). European scholars in the 20th century used the invented story of the Great Fleet (long-distance migrations) and Io cult (creation activities similar to Genesis) as explanations for the settlement and creation of Maori culture as well as to suggest kinship between Maoris and New Zealand’s European settlers in order to help the process of colonization and assimilation to Maori natives. By fabricating a tradition or past history to establish a tie and close relationship (or find more similarities) between Maori and European culture, Europeans could further fulfill their political desires to assimilate Maoris to their cultures. However, the present cultural invention told a different story because at this time, Maoris themselves adopted the tradition distortion and invented stories out of the reason to maintain their cultural distinctiveness and create contrast to other cultures. By portraying their culture as unique and different, Maoris could thus obtain the full ownership and control of their own cultural heritage and acquire political sovereignty in the society. Basically, from the two forms of cultural invention, Hanson showed readers how a culture can be manipulated and represented in different ways to fulfill different purposes.
This article immediately reminds me of “The Ecological Indian” debate between Kretch and Ranco that I studied during the environmental anthropology class. The ecological Indian research by Kretch argued that based on thorough environmental research, Native Americans were not actually environmental conservationists even though they have always been portrayed as one. The true fact is that Native Americans were first depicted and romanized as conservationists by European settlers; but later, Native Americans adopted this conservationist image and incorporated it into their culture and started to actually act like one. Native Americans were willing to distort their culture and history today because they are afraid to lose their political rights and ownership of the land. So very similar to Hanson’s Maori culture study, a culture was originally invented by a foreign group out of political purpose, while later on this invented idea was adopted by the cultural group itself to show its unique cultural identity and maintain political rights. An important issue also emerged from the debate between Kretch and Ranco and I believe it’s worth to include it into the Maori article as well is that whether anthropologists today should reveal all the facts and correct all distorted cultures of a cultural group (even though have to bear the risk of jeopardizing the group’s rights and political sovereignty) or they should continue to perpetuate this fabricated cultures just out of the reason for protecting the group. I believe this is a hard question to answer because there are lots of complex issues on the line; also, there is never a correct answer for this question.
Even though it is very difficult to give a satisfactory answer to this question at this point, it is still worthwhile to take a closer look at the phenomenon of cultural invention and adoption. This phenomenon could be related to the discourse of social inequality under Marxism and World System Theory because the invention and distortion of certain cultures really shows the exploitation to the periphery groups (or lower class, the weak side) by the core groups. And the way exploitation is implemented is by giving a false ideology or fake image to certain cultural groups out of certain political purposes (colonization and assimilation equal to exploitation for labor power from lower class). Even the later adoption of the distorted culture by cultural groups due to the reason of maintaining their cultural uniqueness and protecting political rights reflects the exploitation from the powerful side because in a sense they do not have a choice.
Nice extension of Hanson's discussion, Ruohan, thanks!
ReplyDelete