Social Critics towards Foucault, “The Incitement to Discourse”

 By Hex Li

I found so interesting reading Foucault’s The Incitement to Discourse, as he discussed why, although calling “sex” by its name was a taboo in the 17th century, there was a steady increase of discourse concerned with sex around the 18th century. As a result, I decided to try to apply his theory to Chinese culture’s disencouragement towards forefronted styled criticism. 

As always, let me summarize where Foucault’s argument locates first. Being a post-structuralist, he argued that there isn’t an exact fundamental structure or theory that could explain human’s society or culture, and power can not be possessed by agents; instead, he advocated that power diffuses into society in terms of norms and institutions; in his article, he discussed the steady proliferation of discourse about sex in terms of religional, pedagogical, and medical institutional influence and regulation. One thing worth noticing here is Foucault’s definition of “discourse”. Since I can’t phrase better than Dr. Bender did in the VoiceThread, I would use her words: “discourse is the practice that systematically formed the object of which they speak...through discoursive practices, heterogeneous elements would congeal into a particular structure of mutual determination.” In the case of the discourse of “sex”, influenced by the Catholics and the Council of Trent, the ideology of which original sin and formed evil carried by human flesh result in a feeling of confession; especially with sex, the topic that closely relative with flesh, desire to transform those ugly desires into discourse became a way of making it morally acceptable and technically useful (Foucault, 22). In the beginning of the 18th century, as the population boomed, the means of production improved and division of labor complicated, which led to the development of technology and science. This great leap shifted human’s focus from a more ideological perspective such as religion to realism and materials. Therefore, discourses about sex transformed from a moral issue to a rational issue for research; for example, in the medical industry, discourses of sex shifted from being repressed to being ordered.  Age of marriage, birth rate, and reproduction methods, along with the steep rise of population, sex then became a significant attribute for regulating society (Foucalt, 26). When the discourse of sex came into the pedagogical institution, with German’s “philanthropic” movement, researchers had been advocating that instead of letting the children to be silenced and unconscious about sex in the control of an adult, they should receive a certain discourse which Foucault argued to serve as a kind of discoursive orthopedics. 

In this way, power has changed from a repressive sovereign power to a regulated disciplinary power. All in all, by interpreting the multiplicity of discourses produced by institutions such as religional, medical, and pedagogical, Foucalt emphasized on the multiplicity of the increase of discourse on sex as a product of a series of mechanisms. And his approach is the approach I want to imitate to analyze the discourse of forefront criticism in Chinese history. Being very forefront and criticizing others or things have not been a type of discourse that has been encouraged in Chinese culture until the 21st century. However, there have been constant and massive records in history that violate this seemingly taboo. 

For almost 20 centuries (yea, you are right, not “20th” but “20”), the most dominating pedagogical and moral ideology in China has been Confucianism. As the highest moral principle of Confucianism, the Golden Mean requires people to live and make decisions in the most appropriate way that doesn’t incline to either polar (please don’t just search this concept in Google, 90% of the explanations are wrong). This concept is completely different from eclecticism since the latter could result in losing one’s own principles. One example of the Golden Mean would be represented by a famous saying in China: 学而不思则罔,思而不学则殆; it refers to reading books blindly without thinking would result in the inability to use the knowledge reasonably and effectively, and even get confused by the knowledge. And if you blindly think about an aspect of a thing without actually studying and delving into it, you will end up building a tower on the sand. As a result, it’s important to study and think at the same time. Similar with Focualt’s thinking of binarism which indicates the constructed rather than an immanent property of it, the Golden Mean suggests people to re-consider the polarized concepts by its constructed components and find the most appropriate way to achieve the balance, ideally with manners and one’s principle. In short, it encourages a more considerate solution than polarized criticism.In fact, it’s the solution of the issue that softens the tone of criticism in an objective view, so the aggressiveness still exists when purely looking at the criticism part. Also being similar with Focualt’s example of pedagogical institution’s regulation on the discourse of sex, this pedagogical and moral institutional impact towards the discourse about open criticism then served a kind of discoursive orthopedics: rather than very openly challenge the authority or publicly and verbally oppose others’ opinion, a more rational approach, which still persists in one’s standing, is employed for both socially saving the face for the target and showing the manner and rationality of oneself. 

In terms of the exertion of power from political institutions, interestingly, people presumably expect, since centralized autocratic monarchy--” sovereign power” in Foucalt’s term--had been the dominating political system in China before the 20th century, forefront critics, particularly towards the emperor, would be welcomed and even followed with punishment. But there have been many government officials criticizing the emperor’s policies in history. In fact, the centralized political system welcomed critics from government officials; due to the relatively stabilized power distribution, publicly accepting criticism could consolidate the emperor’s image and status in the heart of the people. Besides, the lack of historical artifacts and documents regarding those critics reveals that the role and position of those who were able to criticize the emperor: the officials’ position cannot be too high or too low, nor too influential or not known at all, thus, the kind of middle-class second-tier regional officials became the emperor's best choice for accepting criticism. The welcomeness towards criticism from these officials was further explained by the frequency of the emperor’s visits in these second-tier cities. There was an obvious tendency that the more visits that the emperor made a year, the more popular and stable both his status and policy would be accepted by the citizens and officials. In addition, it was because those who made criticism were not as significant, the official history that favored the empowerment of the emperor’s authority only recorded the action of the visit of the emperor instead of the details of criticism and the criticizer.  

I know you guys have read enough about my blog at this point, so I would just stop here. In conclusion, what I want to say is that, similar to Foucault’s analysis on the discourse of sex in 17th to 18th century’s Europe by using multiple institutions as the analyzed object to reveal that power is not a possession of agent but a product of various intertwining institutional mechanism that maintains the privileged norm, I decided to use his method to study the discourse regarding forefront criticism which seems to be a way of thinking and acting that devalued in the history of China due to the centralized authority and moral standard. Finally, the fact is that both pedagogical and political institution had been encouraged this discourse: for the pedagogical institution, the encouragement served as a discursive orthopedics that shaped the way that people should carry out their criticism; for the political institution, the welcomeness had only opened for middle-status regional officials for consolidating the image of emperor overall and avoiding power conflict within the higher level of the central government.


Comments

  1. Very intriguing piece, Hex. It is very difficult to pull oneself out of a hegemonic discourse in order to analyze it, but I think you have done it. And it was very useful to weave Foucauldian and poststructuralist concepts throughout the essay. Question to readers: Are there similar processes of (perhaps unwitting) production of attention to "forbidden" topics in discourses that shape our lives?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hex, your analysis of Foucault’s The Incitement to Discourse is very well put, and applying the theoretical framework to Chinese culture’s discouragement towards forefronted styled criticism was complex and well written. I happy you said not to google Confucianism because as soon as you started talking about it, I put it into google. It is one of those concepts I have heard of but do not honestly know what it means. Your description was helpful, so if my comments on it are a little incorrect, I apologize. Your application of the Golden Mean (I’m still not entirely sure what the Golden Mean means, but from your description, I think it serves as the highest moral principle by which someone should lead their lives to achieve) concerning Foucault’s binarism sums up the ways in which consciously considering life around oneself is essential. Personally, I like the stance of considering a solution than polarized criticism to remove the aggressive or hostile element out of the limelight and seems to make it somewhat. Your further discussion on criticism in the context of political power is the most interesting part of your blog post. I think pretty often; criticism is believed to be negative and somewhat damming. As you point out, this is probably based on the desire to maintain power. Power and pressure to maintain power create a false notion of where power comes from; in reality, it is derived from the institutions. So, for power-producing institutions to be legitimized, the criticism of those institutions must be taken in their entirety. In Foucault’s examples of the process by which sex because a political matter, it was necessary to “politicize” the topic. As you point out, the welcomeness towards criticism is clearly evident in the actions of political leaders. Overall, I think this was a significant analysis, Hex. Again, I apologize if I misunderstood the principles of Confucianism.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much Emily to spend time reading my critics and understand all those confusing Chinese philosophical terms. I admitted those are very difficult to understand and people even have been writing books about every single term I mentioned, so I probably didn't explain them well enough as well! but again (this is not a response), I really appreciate your feedback and glad that you response to my post!

      Delete
  3. Everyone, sorry for the format issue; I don't know what happened after I pasted the blog from googledoc.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts