Response To Mitch's "Social-Cultural Critique: Symbolism of Internet Memes and Their Role as an Online Ritual"
I'm not quite sure why Blogger wouldn't allow me to post this as a comment under Mitch's actual post, but here is my response.
BY MEILYN NORMAN
Mitch, I really appreciate your evaluation of memes as a symbolic ritual. It's interesting to consider the way that these images can convey somewhat intangible meanings, and even build upon one another to create an even more complex web of connections. Your interpretation of memes as a ritual of rebellion was extremely interesting to me, given that I hadn’t ever considered the meme as a form of rebellion before. However, it makes sense that these expressions can be used as a way to decrease societal tension. I also think that memes can be interpreted using a poststructural theoretical framework. The use of memes could be imagined as a Foucaldian discourse. For example, memes operate in simultaneously more confined structures (through the use of images and given formats) and less confined structures (ability to innovate and combine different ideas). Therefore, the statements that are permitted and prohibited are both limitless and somewhat constrained to the original concept. Most notably, memes have an interesting way of revealing rules to outsiders. Of course, one can always try to search for the context behind a meme, but many young people understand the meanings of complex combinations without outside information. Anyone can make a meme, but it is evident whether they understand the nuance when the meme is presented to others. Thus, “outsiders” are able to be identified based on their understanding or misunderstanding of different memes. Therefore, the rules governing memes are relatively opaque because a certain knowledge is required to interpret and understand them. In terms of authorship, memes are often created by anonymous internet users, and original creators often cannot be identified because funny memes are passed around the internet without credit to the original creator. Beyond that, memes are not necessarily just made by one person because the meaning is collectively created by many people.
I will attempt to explain the first meme in case anyone is curious. I would guess that an overwhelming majority of the class knows exactly what the meme means at first glance, but it is interesting to break down the creation of a meme and its meaning. I would like to note that I had to search for the origin of some of these elements. Even though I understand the meaning, I am not quite sure of the exact origins of these components, which, in my experience, is true in many cases.
The background image is a still image from the Japanese anime “The Brave Fighter of Sun Fighbird.” The context of the scene is that the human is gesturing to a butterfly, saying “Is this a pigeon?” (The butterfly has been covered by the boot.) The image at the bottom is a still image from the tv show “Tim & Eric, Presidents,” where the actors joke about a free house. The image is taken from a final moment, where Tim Heidecker says the phrase “It’s free real estate.” This image often appears with the text at the bottom, but it doesn’t always have to, since most people understand the meaning without the text. Both of these moments were memorable to audiences, so they were made into memes separately. For example, the “Is this a pigeon?” meme often places an image or text over the boy and butterfly to show something that is misidentified. A Wake Forest meme page posted an meme where “professors” misidentified “reverse classroom,” replacing the bottom text with “Is this teaching?” (Each word, “professors,” “reverse classroom,” and “Is this teaching?” was placed over the appropriate part of the image to convey the speaker and object of misidentification.) Okay, we’re almost there. The snake and boot over the boy and butterfly are a clear reference to the Toy Story famous line, “There’s a snake in my boot!” This is one of the famous phrases Woody says when his string is pulled.
When put together, the meme is saying that the snake is saying “It’s free real estate” about the boot, which is indicating that the snake views the boot as a place that it can inhabit. But the undertone of wrongful identification of the “Is this a pigeon?” meme shows that the snake is incorrect as identifying the boot as “free real estate” (presumably because the boot is not a proper home for a snake). It’s super unfunny after this amount of explanation. I guess the saying “Explaining a joke is like dissecting a frog. You understand it better but the frog dies in the process.” rings true in this instance. (This quote has been attributed to both E.B. White and Mark Twain, so I am not sure who to cite here.)
The meme serves as an exercise in abstract thinking and connections, all of which are elaborately working together to create meaning beyond any one image. To understand the meme, the viewer has to have a good deal of context. I’m honestly not even sure I can articulate the meaning of the meme well through text (without showing examples of other uses of these formats to establish patterns of use). The point that I am trying to make is that, as Mitch indicated, these images are powerful condensations of cultural meanings. These symbols are meant to be understood instantly by viewers of the “inside” group, and obviously they understand this context without intentional interpretation.
Thank you so much for this great comment and translation! This was a great example of symbolic anthropology applied to a specific task of interpretation.
ReplyDelete