“Culture Shock” and Liminality: Socio-Cultural Critique (Haley Smith)

        The concept of “culture shock”, an experience that has increased due to globalization, has been understood psychologically as a universal human experience. The image attached offers the “universal” psychological landscape for the condition of culture shock that follows 4 stages along a parabola: “honeymoon”, “uncertainty and doubt”, “adaption”, and “acceptance”. This psychological process can be articulated as a state of liminality, where an environmental change transitions the individual from unaccustomed to accustomed. 

In this stage, the individual has few of the characteristics of the past or coming state, rendering them vulnerable during this interior change. During the “honeymoon” phase of culture shock, the foreigner is blissfully unaware of their cultural nonconformity and rather focuses on the newness of the environment with optimism. The lack of true awareness of both the self and the new environment allows for this initial state to occur. The familiar is not yet strange and the strange is not yet familiar. The individual still preserves the characteristics of their past and has not truly gained any cultural characteristics of their new present. 

Once the parabola “dips”, or rather the individual enters the “uncertainty & doubt” stage, the state of liminality begins. A key characteristic of liminality is that psychological hardship breaks down belief systems and reconstructs them. Within the context of culture shock, the foreigner begins to truly perceive their own character as out of place and has the fundamentals of their existence, including daily routines, practices and beliefs, challenged and/or removed. For example, during my junior year of high school, I went to live with a family in France and attended school with my exchange student for a month. Initially, I was in awe by the sound of the french language I heard in passing, the sight of southern France’s landscape, and the abundance of new foods at my disposal. However, after about a week, my inability to fully communicate my thoughts and understand my host family’s comments made the sound of the french language almost disturbing to me. The landscape that I once admired for its novel trees and rolling hills was no longer beautiful for its “foreignness”, but rather deeply discomforting. The Atlantic ocean between Lyon and Philadelphia expanded greatly in my mind. 

Next, “adaptation” can be paralleled to the “reconstructing” aspect of liminality

This is when the past, familiar identity of the individual is surrendered in order to assimilate to the new environment and culture. In this case, the once “strange” becomes familiar. Critical to this is the passage of time (see the X-axis in the figure above). Time allows for the creation and eventual dissolution of the liminal state. The extent of the time passed during a liminal period is dependent on the nature of both the previous identity and the concluding identity. In the case of culture shock, some may experience an elongated liminal state along with psychological hardship depending on adaptability. Finally, “acceptance” marks the end of the liminal state where the foreigner has adapted to their new environment and their cognitive state is arguably changed. They are no longer the person they were before their travels. 

Interpretive anthropologists understand the process of liminality to be the most crucial aspect of rites of passage. A “rite of passage” is a permanent transition of identity that is both experienced by the individual as well as the community. Not only does the foreigner experience internal change, but the external culture to which they are adjusting to arguably recognizes them as changed. The ability to perform assimilation to the locals/natives of one’s new environment is arguably a part of leaving the liminal state of culture shock. Because the individual’s psychological landscape has changed, their external behavior and reactions to the environment will be recognizable to the locals around them.

Comments

  1. Nice post! Is culture shock/extreme travel a kind of rite of passage and nexus of liminality for the modern professional/bourgois/upper middle class person in the U.S.?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts