Critique of "Feminist Anthropology: Approaching Domestic Violence in Northern Viet Nam" by Lynn Kwiatkowski
by Freya Zheng
This article, "Feminist Anthropology", by Lynn Kwiatkowski is an expanded elaboration and reflection on the author's anthropological research about domestic violence in Northern Viet Nam. Investigating the influence of intersecting and contradictory local and transnational sociocultural forces on the abused Vietnamese women, Kwiatkowski argues that "even when legal redress is available and when women are able to undertake action on their own behalf, many abused women are still caught up in a Confucian-influenced understanding of women's subordination to men in marriage, and their obligation to sacrifice their own happiness, and even safety, to keep their families together". In other words, from Kwiatkowski's perspective, it is Vietnamese women's multiple identities, ideology, and value of maintaining family harmony that essentially make legal measures against domestic violence to be less effective.
In order to better understand the situation of gender violence there, several approaches and theories Kwiatkowski has applied to the research include: 1) analyzing gender violence cross-culturally and from various levels; 2) investigating the changing, multiple ideologies of gender and violence that shape women's subject positions and their subjectivities in Vietnam; 3) incorporating the multiple and contradictory discourses on gender in societies, and 4) Conducting feminist anthropological ethnography of both frontline workers and abused women, "in the context of a society undergoing significant sociocultural change" (238).
To be honest, while admitting that female perspective and ideology do take an important role when evaluating the social status of women in society, I do not think women and their family values are the ones to blame for the persistence of domestic violence in modern society. Firstly, let's talk about the so-called "Confucian-influenced understanding of women's subordination to men in marriage" brought up by the author. There has surely been a misunderstanding of Confucianism that women are always subordinate to men in the ideology of Confucius not only in western countries but also in eastern countries including China itself, where Confucianism has originated. In the article, the author used the "four virtues" to generalize the Confucian principles for women and family power structure - "they were taught to be hardworking, neat and humble in appearance, soft-spoken and self-controlled in their speech, and filial, loyal, kind, and trustworthy in their behavior" (241). What the author forgets to mention here is that the Confucian ideology, more importantly, requires the male roles in a family to be righteous and moral, respecting their mothers, wives, and daughters. A quote from Confucius' Analects says that "wife should listen to her husband only if he has morality and righteousness" ("夫义,妇听"), from which we could say that it is unfair to blame the Confucian ideology as the main reason for the persistence of domestic violence in Vietnam. Secondly, throughout history, religion and ideology have long been used as political tools for the governors to rule their citizens. "Males taking a more powerful role in society" and "males, as the governor, using Confucianism as a political tool", being two separate facts, does not necessarily lead to the conclusion that "Confucian femininity encourages males to commit violence or disencourages females to resist violence". Therefore, instead of using Confusian ideology as the shield, it is more proper and accurate to say that it is the long-oppressed political status, social status, and males' immorality that have hindered women's freedom from domestic violence.
Another point that I would like to bring about is the importance of females taking on higher-level administrative roles in various field. In the articles, Kwiatkowski mentioned that when the battered women were seeking help from social organizations and official institutions, the only suggestion that they got was to "make peace in their family". Sadly speaking, Vietnam is surely not the only place in the world that could not offer females with the actual help they need. I have heard of so many similar examples in China, where women going to the police office to seek help and asking the officers to arrest their husbands, and it turned out that the only feedback they received was "it is your personal problem within your own family, we can do nothing about it". Undoubtedly, most of the officers who would say that to the battered women were males. Males, who grow up with more conveniences and privileges, normally are not able to put themselves into women's shoes and be equally supportive when they are needed. Similar examples can also be found in other sexist situations, such as education and workplace discrimination. However, having more females to take administrative roles and make decisions is never an easily achievable goal since it also intersects with not only the political and economic conditions, but the "cultural mechanisms and structural inequalities that inadvertently perpetuate gender violence" (252).
Hi, Freya!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed your post on the feminist anthropology. I found your critique very interesting and fascinating, especially the part when you discussed that “instead of using Confusian ideology as the shield, it is more proper and accurate to says that it is the long-oppressed political status, social status, and males' immorality that have hindered women's freedom from domestic violence'' as well as the part concerning the lack of support and protection to women who suffered from domestic violence. I found the interpersonal support and existence of helping groups are extremely important today to help combat the domestic violence issues, especially helping victims recover from the harm and reconstruct a new life. I got this idea from Mattingly’s article “Luck, Friendship, and the Narrative Self". Both Sasha from the Mattingly’s article and Vietnam women from Kwiatkowski’s article suffered from tremendous pain in their life, however, the way and result of their moral transformation have been very different, or even contradictory. In Mattingly’s article, Sasha gradually recovered from the pain and started to embrace a new life with positivity, while most women in Vietnam who suffered from domestic violence chose to stay where they were, even a large number of them tried to persuade other women just to endure it. I am very curious what caused the difference in the results in moral transformation between the two parties. And I think social ideology, social status of women and interpersonal assistance can all be taken into account. In the two articles, Sasha and Vietnam women are actually playing two different social roles. One is a mother who is expected to be strong and brave for children, while the other is a wife who is expected to be obedient and submissive to husband (especially under the influence of Confucianism and the social status of women in Vietnam is lower). Another important influence is that Sasha received lots of interpersonal support from family and friends to help her conduct self-reflection and self-criticism, while Vietnam women did not even have a good and consistent platform for them to connect with others and receive support, or have a chance to actually reflect and think about the matter. Therefore, I completely agree with you that in order to help women in Vietnam combat with domestic violence, more attention should be put on the long-oppressed social ideology and social status of women as well as platforms for interpersonal support to help victims not only recover from the pain but also complete successful moral transformations.
Great discussion. Thanks, Freya and Ruohan!
ReplyDelete