Critique of Douglas's "External Boundaries"

 

BY HALEY SMITH

Mary Douglas’s chapter titled “External Boundaries” argues that the human body is a universally potent symbol of society and each culture’s unique bodily symbolism illustrates and reaffirms its societal structures. The excretory substances of the human body, such as breast milk and saliva, become symbolic products that can tell us about a culture’s social structure. Drawing off of Van Gennep’s ideas about liminality, bodily fluids operate in a liminal space, where they come from the body, but have also left its boundary. Douglas argues against psychologist’s theory that bodily rituals are more common in “primitive” societies, “whose personality resembles that of infants or neurotics” (425).  Douglas states that bodily-based symbols and societal understandings of bodily fluids are culturally situated and bodily rituals do not have to do with varying levels of cognitive ability. Heavily influenced by Durkheim, Douglas viewed culturally situated symbols of the body and understandings of bodily fluid to be social facts. 

She explores the body as a symbol of power and danger through her anthropological analysis of the Hindu caste system. This central example is arguably the strongest aspect of her work as she evaluates how the concepts of pollution and purity along the lines of caste and gender preserve the strict social hierarchy. The social order in areas dominated by Hinduism is divided by the caste system, where Brahmins (priests) are at the top and Dalits exist outside of the system and are deemed “untouchable”. Douglas argues that the caste system is preserved by culturally situated notions of pollution and purity. Lower caste members are constricted to their caste through their proximity to certain bodily fluids while higher caste members preserve their status by maintaining distance from polluted items, fluids, and people. Douglas claims that purity and pollution act as symbolic boundaries that partition society into a functioning hierarchy. I think, in the case of Hindu culture, the theory that society is mirrored by an understanding of the human body is a valid argument. However, Douglas is attempting to make the statement that because the human body is a universal experience, societal functioning mirrors that of the cultural understanding of the human body. If she is to make this large of a statement, the chapter is in need of more cultural examples. It seems as though the mirroring of the individual human body and society is generally true for Hindu society, but I am not necessarily convinced that variations of this exist in other cultures as she suggests. 

Finally, Douglas states that female purity in Hindu society is highly related to sexual activity. She writes, “...a woman who is known to have had sexual intercourse with a man of lower caste is brutally punished” (Douglas 429). Thus, an intersectional form of discrimination and punishment occurs when women engage in “impure” behavior, particularly with someone outside of their caste. Yet, “a mere ritual bath is enough to cleanse a man from sexual contact with a low caste woman” (429). When thinking about how we can apply this piece today, this aspect of Douglas’s work made me think about the archaic yet prevalent understandings of female sexual purity in the United States. Although there has been a lot of work done to combat this, the idea that women are in some sense “tainted” by sexual activities, particularly out of wedlock, continues to endure. Within the context of social structuring, we can understand the idea that female sexual promiscuity as a sign of “pollution” is a form of social control. Within the context of a patriarchal society, female subordination is preserved through sexual shaming. Female contact with others within a sexual context is seen as “polluting”, while male contact with sexual partners is either celebrated or deemed neutral. The sexual boundaries set up for women help preserve gender inequality. Douglas reminds us that notions of purity and impurity that surround the body can help preserve societal hierarchies. 


Comments

  1. This is Haley Smith by the way^ Forgot to put my name in by-line

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very nice discussion of the article and its applicability. I can't tell if you agree with Douglas or not in the end because though you fault her for not providing more cross-cultural examples, you then jump in with a good one of your own!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts