Critique of The Cultural Ecology of India’s Sacred Cattle
BY ELLEN GUNN
In The Cultural Ecology of India’s Sacred Cattle, Harris counters the tendency to criticize ahimsa, India’s sacred cow complex, as a “mismanagement
of resources” or an economically destabilizing practice founded upon an adherence to “irrational”
religious beliefs. Establishing that sacred cattle serve as elements of the “Indian cultural landscape,”
Harris emphasizes that perhaps the ahimsa “ taboos, customs and rituals… [are]
‘positive-functioned’” and subsequently, may be “‘adaptive’ processes of the ecological system
of which they are a part” (Harris, 1992, 261). A contrast to analyses of ahimsa’s impact on
“national market sector”, an interpretation that evaluates economic productivity of India on the
basis of comparison to Western production standards, Harris argues that when positioned in their
respective Indian ecological landscape, sacred cattle and humans share a symbiotic, rather than a
competitive relationship (Harris, 1992, 262).
According to Harris, in the Indian ecological landscape, which is composed by the animal and
plant species, and social hierarchy and ideology, “darwinian pressures” act upon both the human
and cow populations. Hence, Harris posits that the profound influence of these pressures appear
in Hindu adherence to the ahimsa taboos against slaughtering cows and eating beef. Together, these
practices offer material gains for both humans and the animals, which subsequently promote the
continual “power and substance” of ahimsa (Harris, 1992, 262). To support his hypothesis, Harris
conducts an analysis of the role ahimsa plays in the following principle spheres: (1) Milk
Production, (2)Traction, (3) Dung (4) Beef and Hides and the following secondary spheres:
(5) Pasture, (6) Useful and Useless Animals, (7) Slaughter, (8) Anti-slaughter Legislation,
(9) Old Age Homes, and (10) Natural Selection. Given that this should be a short blog entry,
I will solely cover the primary spheres, which I believe to support Harris' hypothesis and critical
process most clearly.
In regards to milk production, Harris counters the conclusion that the lower levels of cow milk
production in India relative to Europe and the U.S. is indicative of resource mismanagement. To
do so, Harris shows that in India, the sacred cow is not intended to contribute primarily to milk
production. In fact, it is the female buffalo that is the primary milk producer, while the cows are
more so valued for their ability to produce bulls (Harris, 1992, 263). Even so, it is crucial to note
that 46.7% of Indian dairy products still are derived from cow's milk, which implies that cow milk
production is not insufficient in the Indian context (Harris, 1992, 263). Moving into traction, Harris
argues that sacred cattle serve as the principal mechanisms by which farmers plow their grain fields.
In fact, as an essential process for initiating the “agricultural” cycle, Harris even finds that the
amount of cattle available per farmer to be insufficient.
Observing the principality of grain in the diet of rural communities, Harris also notes that most grain
must be cooked to be edible, a process that relies upon “domestic cooking fuel”, which is sourced
primarily from cow dung. In addition to the contribution of dung to cooking fuel, cow dung also
functions as manure, which offers important contributions to the fertility of the farmers’ land
. Ultimately, given the taboos of cow slaughter and consumption, the most surprising contribution
of India’s sacred cattle are cow hides and beef. As Harris points out, the Indian ecosystem is not
solely composed of Hindus, but also Muslims and “exterior” groups such as the lowest untouchable
class. Members of the depressed castes at times make use of cow hide and skin. Moreover, in
extenuating circumstances, dead cattle may serve as a necessary source of protein for these
disadvantaged populations -- an option that Harris theorizes to be hypothetically improbable if
it were not for the taboo of beef consumption (Harris, 1992, 264).
In each of these examples, Harris aims to unravel the tendency of western audiences to deem
ahimsa as an exotic, irrational and economically infeasible practice. Encouraging a look into the
Indian ecological landscape, Harris highlights the importance of analyzing a practice through an
investigation of its uses and contributions to its respective environment. Hence, it appears that
Harris aims to promote a degree of cultural relativism, by which cultural practices must be evaluated
against their respective standards rather than the standards of others. In my view, this promotion is
most evident in Harris’ evaluation of milk production among sacred cattle. In his evaluation, Harris
begins by establishing the primary role of female cows as milk producers in the United States and
Europe. Because of this, he notes that westerners assume that cows India must also be used primarily
for their milk-producing abilities, which leads to the misguided conclusion that Indian sacred cattle
are being misused as resources. Hence, Harris emphasizes the ways in which western biases can
promote unfavorable attitudes towards ahimsa.
In my view, such an emphasis indicates that this article is geared towards revising perceptions of
non-western practices among western audiences, a project that may be perceived as a strength
insofar as Harris promotes the adoption of a less-biased interpretive lens. Even so, it is also crucial
to note that the audience of the article is limited and in turn, serves to evaluate the broad scale
relationship between ahimsa and its ecological context for westerners. Focusing solely on the
material contributions of ahimsa across a breadth of productive spheres, Harris’ article lacks a
personable ethnographic dimension. Consequently, he overlooks the attitudes of the Indian people
towards ahmisa, which reduces the credibility of Harris’ conclusions insofar as they cannot be
affirmed, denied, or expanded upon from an emic standpoint.
Excellent review of Harris' theory and data. You also do an elegantly balanced job of highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of the approach!
ReplyDelete