Critics towards Wolf’s “Facing Power”

Hex Li

To be honest, I don’t want to call this as a critique of Wolf’s “Facing Power”, because I do subscribe to his four different modes of power. But I want to elaborate a bit on his interpretation, and re-classify power into different forms. Before diving into my thoughts, let me summarize Wolf’s beliefs. Being neo-Marxian and realist, Wolf subscribed to Marx’s argument about which exploitation is the driving force of history; at the same time, he went beyond Marxian’s concentration on external social order and materials, and focused on the diachronic historical influence, political economy, cultural interplayed complexity, and multinational perspective (589, Wolf). In addition, impacts from Boasian ideology has definitely revealed in his work of “Facing Power”, as he in the last section, Signification, pointed out that, rather to perceive a symbol’s meaning as a result from a automatic process, we should understand it as a consequence and result through conflicts between powers; it’s being said that the context and historical aspect of the symbol is a necessity for analyzing meaning, which echoed with the cultural relativism from Boasian ideology. Beside, he also supported Levi Stauss’s idea of “surplus of signifier”(592, Wolf), revealing the over-analysis and misinterpretation of symbols. 

In our reading of Facing Power, he further elaborated on the term “power”. Individual, interactional/social, organizational, and structural, these are the four different modes of power. Individual power symbolizes the attribute of a person; interactional/social power emphasizes the capacity of impose a will on an alter in social action; organizational power controls the settings in which people display their potentialities and interact with others. It allocates resources to establish relationships between individuals; however, organizational is not absolute; it is constantly being challenged, as friction would be aroused through the enactment of power (590, Wolf). There are two important properties of organization, according to Wolf: firstly, organizational is a finished product of different labelling in different culture; for example, while the US has parliament resulted from the historical causes of democracy, China has Central Commission for Discipline Inspection (CCDI), who specifically focuses on government officials’ corruption, originated from one of the most essential ancient China’s cultural standard of honest and incorruptible (清廉, it’s hard to translate into the exact same meaning). Meanwhile, organization is also a process, answering the question of “how organizations and institutions can relate sets of people with various background and the structural power they represented together.” For me, the fourth mode of power, structural power, can structure both the existing field of action and possible field of actions. Other than the example of capital that Wolf provides, gender, race, sexuality, the attributes related with human-formed social norms and stereotypes can all be considered as structural power. 

Although Wolf has already put “power” in modes, I would argue that it’s inadequate to classify power in terms of its affected range; as a result, I purpose to classify power in terms of the degree of explicitness of power, due to its complexity. What I have aligned with Wolf is his focus on organizational and structural mode of power, so all of my arguments below would be built upon the last two modes. (however, my classification can also be employed on an individual and interactional level; it’s just, being a anthropology student, I want to focus on the latter two more.) In the first degree of power, power should be very obvious, simply represented by the favored group. The favored/privileged group can affect the actions of the ther groups and profit from it. An example would be how the US government back in the 18th century legitimized slavery for the increase in economy and for the prestige group of slavery owner. In the second degree of power, power should be less observable but construct itself diachronically; social norms, stereotypes, and even racism are the products of this degree of power, as power would create obstruction to issue to enter the discussion table. Many researcher such as Hoschild and Goffman have been studied on how stereotypes, feeling rules, and racism are continuously enhanced; even our course reading on Boellstorff’s  Emergence of Political Homophobia mentioned about this topic: as the Indonesian government had been putting effort to construct a national masculinity after colonization, femininity and masculinity had been portrayed in a certain image and standard (470, Boellstorff). Through the institutional effort to promote stereotypes and taboos, the undermined issues become more silenced, and the associated groups become more marginalized; therefore, power in this way, by continually reinforcing a certain type of ideology, gradually silenced and creates barriers for the issue to be shed lights on. 

Last, but not least, power can also manipulate potential challenger’s thinking to avoid their awareness of conflict in interest which would prevent the future argument. For example, the famous American dream is a cultural tool for the US government to conceal and shape the general publics’ consciousness towards the fact that they are being exploited by the capitalist system. By positively appraising the hard-work of individuals and highlighting the absolute cause-and-effect relationship between effort and success, the government can shape the citizen’s value system and allow them to blame themselves for their own failure without even considering the flaws and structural issues. Especially through the nowadays booming development of media and technology, this cultural ideology which especially signifies the glory and proud aspect--the equalness and openness of the US--of the American culture is more wide-spread and reinforced through propaganda from institutions, advertisements from commercial, and literature in all forms, such as movies.


Comments

  1. Very interesting. I agree with you that we can further problematize power in terms of its qualities and nature, not just its range of application or associated institutions.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts