The Complex Relationship between Recording Cultures and the Internet

    Franz Boas developed the practice of preserving disappearing cultures, known as salvage ethnography, around the turn of the twentieth century with the intention to study rapidly disappearing Native American studies. Boas and his students saw value in learning about the cultures and languages which were being wiped out by American imperialism and colonialist approaches. Although the practice of salvage ethnography has fallen out of the norm due to its rapid method of fieldwork and its focus on a culture's past rather than its present, the idea of treating all cultures with respect and recording their traditions has evolved into a more dedicated form of fieldwork. This moralistic field ethnography spread worldwide, with anthropologists studying cultures everywhere, focusing on the present version of the culture and their current relationship to the world. In the last twenty to thirty years, a new factor has had a drastic impact on almost every person and culture on the planet - the internet. The almost instantaneous exchange of information from computers to laptops and now to cellphones across the planet has become the most powerful cultural tool since language itself was invented. So this brought me to ask - how has the internet, with its massive and undeniable impact on the whole world, impacted the search for changing cultures, and what have been the effects on the recording of those cultures? Here I'll speculate in a non-exhaustive manner on possible impacts of the internet on cultures which may be studied by ethnographers and the internet's relationship with ethnographers themselves.

    First we'll cover the negatives. First of all, the internet is a culture all its own: everyone from scammers to trolls to people simply not being socially conscious has access, along with the people who want to do good or use the internet as a pool of information. This culture is without a doubt dominated by western nations simply by means of origin and greatest access to internet-enabled devices. However, as the internet spread, and is still spreading, to communities across the world which are traditionally isolated, it is possible that there is a phenomenon occurring which I will call "cultural shifting" in this blog. Cultural shifting is a possible side effect of cultural dissemination. Cultural dissemination is not bad itself - adopting cultural elements can be healthy for a community, and can aid in the development of understanding between cultures. However, cultural shifting is the darker possibilities of cultural dissemination. Members of a culture, especially younger ones, might adopt more and more of the world's worth of culture provided by the internet rather than invest knowledge into their own culture. This rapid adoption of culture as provided by the internet might contribute to the complete change and globalization of a culture, as the younger members of a culture never learn certain traditions as a result of the innocent exchange of information. The internet is also a place of business, and business has a history of mistreating people who have no means of defense against it. Imagine if the purchase of Manhattan Island by the Dutch East India company from the Lenape could have occurred by the click of a button. It is likely that similar events might occur, if they have not already, with the capabilities of businesses to reach out to communities in need of financial assistance and abuse their land or their people as a workforce. Finally, anthropologists themselves must be aware that when they go to study a culture, they are themselves bringing their own culture with them, and today many anthropologists might use the internet and its variety of tools and functions to aid with their study, but this also brings a small risk of internet contamination to communities which may depend on being isolated.

    There are of course, benefits to the use of the internet for field ethnography as well. For instance, in the negatives section I brought up how ethnographers may use the internet as a tool for conducting research. Likely, there are few tools more powerful - the instant taking of notes which can be stored in a weightless cloud of data, accessible over most of the planet and easily organized, is a great boon for an ethnographer to have in the field. The ability to reach out to fellow anthropologists to request advice or aid on issues which arise in the field is valuable; the ability to organize questionnaires and polls, or create community maps with a few drags of a finger, is valuable; the ability to create and save pictures and recordings of cultural events without preparing a bulky camera is valuable. There is no doubt that the internet provides plenty of utility, and ethnographers would be foolish to not consider using it to aid their research. But what positive impacts would the internet have on a community itself? Much like the possible detriments of the internet this would be situation/culture dependent, but we can speculate on a few possibilities. First, when learning about other cultures through the internet, people may grasp more tightly on to their traditional culture rather than change it. People very well may see other cultures and find comfort in the familiarity of their own. Access to the internet and the outside world also may provide a way for a culture to adapt and survive. For example, there is a church in Mexico which blends Christianity with a traditional religion which values burping as a way of purging evil - and so they have begun to use Coca-Cola as a part of their religious ceremonies. Using the increasingly globalized world to the advantage of your culture is a possibility, and for cultures being researched by ethnographers, may be a source of hope.

    Personally, I believe that the internet is such a large and universal phenomenon that we as anthropologists can only hope to use it to our advantage as we continue to try to preserve and study the many cultures of the world. We must also be aware of our impact on the internet, both as anthropologists and as people - it may be impossible to stop the socio-cultural effects of the internet, but we must attempt to make the internet a place which all cultures have a place in, so that every culture and community can begin to thrive in the digital world, and record their own culture on the digital ark of the internet.

by RJ Pratt

Comments

  1. RJ, this was an excellent discussion on the impact of the internet on salv age ethnography. I truly had never thought of the internet spreading to a region that previously had no access as a potentially bad thing. I liked how you coined the term "cultural poisoning" because in a sense, that is exactly what can happen to another culture. While it is important to preserve one's own culture from the point of view of an anthropologist, the generations we are a part of and the ones to come will be exposed to western media through the introduction of the internet to their society and will likely reject some of the more important practices in the culture they are surrounded by. Mixing cultures can be a great thing or a terrible thing, because they can either coexist or slowly one replaces the other in a group of people over time. The internet fast-tracks this decline. I hope that with growing access to western media and ideals the world does not slowly morph into one super-culture, because society only advances when specific traits from a large pool or cultures spread and we adopt things from one another. In this global hive-mind possibility, there is no innovation, and language, culture, and religion will become one. I also liked the point you made about the ability for trolls and scammers to take advantage of new/inexperienced internet users. I think some of the tools we get from the internet will ultimately help in the practice of salvage ethnography, because it makes anthropologists' jobs much easier and faster, and can spread information about declining cultures with the world, so people will begin to join the effort in cultural preservation. Overall, well done!

    ReplyDelete
  2. RJ, I appreciate your great overview of salvage ethnography’s relationship with the internet. Your discussion of the positives and negatives of the internet on disappearing or endangered cultures made me wonder if there were any visible examples of this phenomena. An interesting case related to this topic involves the Sámi people of the Northern Scandinavian Peninsula. Living mainly in the present-day countries of Norway, Sweden, and Finland, the Sámi are the only indigenous group in these highly modernized and technologically advanced states.

    The Sámi living in Finland traditionally have spoken 4 distinct dialects, but this has effectively been reduced to one main dialect for online use and government communication: Northern Sami (or Davvisámegillii in the language). I think your concept of ‘cultural poisoning’ is relevant to the Sámi, as Finland has very high usage rates of the internet - government surveys found that 96-98% of Finns under 45 use the internet regularly. To participate in online culture, Sámi youth do not have a choice except to use Finnish or English. Over time, this could mean Sámi languages become less widely spoken and traditions less practiced as young people are pushed in the direction of a more national cultural identity.

    However, you do note that the internet could enhance salvage ethnography as an ideal method to preserve and encourage practice of cultural heritage. In regard to the Sámi, the Finnish Sámi Parliament has several online educational initiatives for cultural and linguistic preservation. While daily practice of the language and traditions may eventually decrease, a robust collection of self-reported information about Sámi culture will remain accessible online. This seems to be a positive development for preserving the culture and could be applied to other disappearing cultures with internet access.

    Information about Sámi culture and dialects: http://www.sorosoro.org/en/sami-languages/
    Finnish Sámi Parliament website: https://www.samediggi.fi/task/?lang=en
    Government statistics on internet usage in Finland: http://www.stat.fi/til/sutivi/2018/sutivi_2018_2018-12-04_tie_001_en.html

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts