Socio-Culture Critique of Greek Life and Who It Excludes

 BY: LISETTE VICTORIA SAN PEDRO

When examining structuralism, binary oppositions are key in understanding social activity and the way it operates. Within the context of Wake Forest, a binary exists between Greek Life and those who are non-affiliated (often referred to as Geeds). Although, one’s decisions to not join Greek life can be one’s own agency, these decisions should also be understood in terms of its relationship to the entire system. Not to mention, Wake Forest’s Greek life is dominant on campus and rejecting social standards can lead to group punishment. As stated by Durkheim, behaviors and thoughts outside of the individual are “endowed with a forceful coercive power”, which are often thrusted upon someone unwillingly or in fear of exclusion. On the same note, Wake Forest’s institutional dynamic perpetuate such habits, excluding many in the process.

I reside in the space of Magnolia Scholars on Wake’s campus, which offers several insights into the Demon Deacon Culture. As a Mag Scholar it is quickly learned that you encompass a very specific niche within Wake that many cannot relate to. Not only are you a first generation student, but you are also 100% supported by Wake’s financial aid. This sets us apart on Campus and limits us to much of Wake’s social inclusion. Apart from the apparent cultural differences, Wake Forest students engage in excessively rich endeavors that many can not partake in. In this case, finances are the largest obstacle to joining Greek Life. To clarify, I am assuming one is actively willing to be a brother or sister, which often can not be said of many poorer students on campus because of stark cultural differences, however in this case it is not being considered. These differences create binaries in every category including speech, dress, or even vacation patterns.

The median family income of a student at Wake Forest is $221,500, and 71% of students come from the top twenty percent, where 2.3% of students come from the bottom twenty percent. These numbers coincide with the information I received from Wake Forest staff who concluded that almost seventy percent of Wake's students pay the full tuition. Moreover, university is already a hard environment for poor students to accommodate, but once on campus, their financial status may inhibit them from common practices due to the silencing of their minuscule populations. Wake Forest is known for its rich family legacies, fraternity networking, and generous donations from alumni, hence, students unknown to this reality face obstacles when understanding their role in Wake’s homogenous culture.

When analyzing Wake’s homogenous culture, it is easy to reduce almost every part of culture into binaries. These binaries then affect who can partake in Frat life. For instance, students who are financially supported by their parents or not, students who have culturally assimilated or not, or students who have free time or not. On a campus where the majority of students are financed by their parents, pleasurable experiences are at the forefront on weekends. These activities include going out to eat, Mountain Weekend, or a local vineyard and although these activities are accessible to some, performing these weekends on a recurring basis excludes a multitude of people. Additionally, work-study is common practice within every Magnolia Scholar because of their additional aid received from the Federal government. However, the juggling of tedious course work and an on-campus job leaves for little to no free time affecting the physical and mental wellbeing of students. The additional stressors from working on campus are not experienced by students who can devote their attention to places they deem fit, where students on scholarship are forced to sacrifice their time. A work-life balance encountered by Federal work students is a structural dynamic needed to afford classes and personal expenses. This often results in emotional burnout within scholarship students and is a common behavior found among student workers. Lastly, race and ethnicity are largely associated with economic differences on campus and one’s inability to assimilate to a white, Northeastern, rich culture forces student of color to feel like outsiders, creating another binary. A binary of insider or outsider.

The importance of financial stability in a student’s life is obviously priority because fraternities and sororities are extremely expensive. At least on Wake’s campus dues can range from eight hundred to a thousand dollars per semester. Multiple financial structures in a student’s life will obstruct them from even considering fraternity life. Additionally, Wake’s administration perpetuates these systems because of their constant protection of fraternities. Wake has time and time again ignored blatant rule breaking from frats because of loyal donating giving alumni. The Greek system at Wake makes more by ignoring injustices, then creating accessible, safe spaces for poorer and or students of color. Furthermore, it is important to consider the structural dynamic of Frat life because it emphasizes the lack of agency many students have when making important social decisions on campus.


(my Ethnographic Methods paper involved this topic and various structures that harm poor students agency on campus, so it is a topic I find very important on our campus). 

Comments

  1. Lisette Victoria, I really enjoyed reading through your socio-cultural critique of Greek life at Wake Forest. While I was aware of the binary of Greek life vs. non-Greek life, I had not thoroughly considered the other binaries that you laid out, and how they impact Wake Forest’s student body. I completely agree that the race and socio-economic status of students is a major contributor to who is welcomed and who is excluded from Greek life. Not only are expensive sorority and fraternity dues used as a gate keeper, but the material culture associated with each fraternity and sorority such as clothing and accessories also work to prevent people from joining as well. The only thing that I would disagree with is your point that “Wake Forest’s Greek life is dominant on campus and rejecting social standards can lead to group punishment.” From what I have seen during my time at Wake, the student body is, for the most part, evenly split between Greek life and non-Greek life. While I agree that students can be rejected from Greek life, I don’t think that this leads to group punishment and social isolation because those people still have ample opportunity to build social ties with people that are not in a fraternity or sorority. Also, there are whole organizations geared towards students that want to socialize outside of Greek life as well.

    You also mentioned that students of color are often pressured into assimilating to a white, rich northeastern culture, and that if they can’t assimilate they are made to feel like they don’t belong, contributing to an outsider vs. insider binary. I’m interested to hear your perspective on the multicultural sorority, Delta Xi Phi. Do you think that this outsider vs. insider binary will be reduced through Greek organizations that are specifically geared toward students of color?

    Lastly, I liked how thorough you were in examining the several binaries that contribute to Wake Forest’s Greek vs. Non-Greek system. From economic stability vs. instability, students with work study vs. more leisure time, to Magnolia scholars vs. legacy students, each of these helps deepen the divide between Greeks and “Geeds”. I think that it would be an interesting anthropological study to look at whether these individual binaries are more prominent, or if they are more frequently just grouped into the singular binary Greek vs. Non-Greek. This would be similar to how US politics are grouped primarily into Democrat vs. Republican despite there being several individual disagreements and views on various policies and institutions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I enjoyed reading your post on inclusionary and exclusionary complexes/practices at Wake! The ways in which you critique of Greek life and financial exclusivity reminds me a lot my ethnographic research methods project, which focused in on how finance majors in a fraternity utilized language to establish and reinforce a common group identity. As a result of my research, I found that speech (phrase, tone, words, content) worked to set this group of participants apart from students outside of the business major who did not have the same exposure to and familiarity with particular course material, career workshops, networking opportunities, and even study spaces.
    While conducting study research, there were many moments when I had to try very hard to step outside of a critical non-business major position. Overall, it can be quite frustrating to see the amount of money that flows into business school as opposed to other departments. Additionally, due to different admission standards for the business school, there exists an association drawn between intelligence and/or success and students in the business school. While humanities degrees are deemed “useless”, Business school degrees are deemed "useful" and “respectable.”
    In my experience, it seems as though from the get-go freshman boys are urged to consider the business school to seek some level of academic or social validation. I would say that a concentration of finance majors seem to be fraternity men who often come from wealthy families with ties to the industry. Overall, it would be interesting to look further into how the social facts underlying Greek life and the business school may work alongside each other to exclude or include particular types of individuals.
    As Mitch notes, in your response you draw upon many binaries that contribute to Wake’s Greek/non-Greek system. In some cases, one’s position and experiences within the binaries you mention (i.e. insider/outsider, resulting from race, socioeconomic standing) may conflict with the demands and ideals of the coercive Greek complex. Perhaps it could be fruitful to look closer into how an individual manipulates and compromises certain facets their individual identity to fit within a dominant complex. If approached from an attention to binaries, I wonder how Levi-Strauss’ notion of binary oppositions could be collapsed into Durkheim’s understanding of the interplay between the individual and social fact(s). In a society that, according to Durkheim, is cohesive through difference, how exactly does the movement between the “different” individual and “cohesive” collective play out in terms of oppositional binaries? Does some kind of balancing or reconfiguration of binaries occur as result of this process?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ellen, I am fascinated by your comment about how individuals fit their identity into the coercive Greek complex. In particular, I think Greek life actively encourages (and sometimes pressures) individual members to participate in certain social practices. These social practices form larger social structures comprising the whole network of social experiences in Greek life. For example, practices like hazing and pre-gaming encourage the wider social expectation of heavy drinking. If one decides to opt out, they may be ridiculed or excluded. Thus, this structure is often coercive and demonstrates the power of social norms over the actions of individuals.

      One set of social practices in Greek life connected to drinking is hook-up culture. Hook-up culture occurs where prestige is tied to one's sexual activities. Hook-up culture is often fueled by practices of heavy drinking or other substance use. The hyper-competition present in much of Greek life encourages individuals to fulfill these social expectations. Unfortunately, hook-up culture and expectations of heavy drinking often do not mix well. This could be one explanation for another recurrent social phenomena in/around Greek life: sexual harassment and violence.

      Clearly, there are many other factors in instances of sexual abuse on college campuses, but the discussed social structures surely contribute to the problem. These social structures could shape an individual's identity into different parts. Importantly, many display a unique identity for Greek life contexts. That is to say, individuals engage in activities they would mostly likely not participate outside the context of a Greek life event. This raises an important question: is this a conscious choice to engage in more risky behaviors? Or, is Greek life so essential to social life as a whole that one finds it worth the trouble to fake/produce an alternate identity?

      In "From Jíbaro to Crack Dealer", Bourgois addresses similar questions through discussions of incidences where Julio engages in practices of violent theft and assault. Bourgois does not make assumptions or claims about Julio's agency, only that his social position may condition his behavior in powerful ways. Despite his poor situation, Bourgois points out that Julio is not an innocent - he is committing crime; these actions are wrong. Perhaps this same concept should apply to poor actions in Greek life contexts. Yes, individuals may be conditioned to a certain degree by social expectations of heavy drinking, hyper-competition, hook-up culture, and the sort of 'machismo' attitude governing some fraternities. However, whoever causes injury is ultimately responsible for one's actions. I think this distinction is an important boundary for ethnography: we mustn't be afraid to point out clear moral judgments, but it is inappropriate to impose our personal opinions on the ethnographic data itself.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts