Social-Cultural Critique of Partisan Politics

BY ALLY SWARTZBERG

  The structure of American partisan politics often lends itself to a categorization of individuals into binary groups -- most obviously, of Democrat versus Republican.  Within each of these parties are further binarisms; each party is presumed to include members of certain racial groups, socio-economic classes, religions, gender identities, and regions -- each of which are themselves characterized as "distinct" groups of individuals with defined membership boundaries.  This is an example of Sapir's concept of "social behavior" as the behavior of  groups of "human beings which act as such, regardless of the mentalities of the individuals which compose the groups." If you look to each of these parties' most vocal candidates and their platforms, you'd notice a consistency across issues: the positions of Democratic candidates on taxation, public education, reproductive health, gun rights, healthcare, and foreign policy appear on paper to directly oppose those of their Republican counterparts.  

  Where Levi-Strauss and the French structuralist school considered the "universal" human tendency toward the creation of particular binary categorizations, Sapir, influenced by the Boasian concept of Cultural Relativism, argued that "the more carefully we study cultural behavior, the more thoroughly we become convinced that the differences are but differences of degree... [which] lie in the unconsciously apprehended builds of the respective social patterns which include them and out of which they have been abstracted for an essentially artificial comparison." If one were to consider the American example of partisan politics more closely, they would notice a spectrum of beliefs and values within the members of each party, a variety of less prominent parties which impact the likelihood of election for both majority parties, and a not insignificant minority of individuals across the ideological spectrum who do not subscribe to the values of any major national party and feel alienated from the productive workings of the public sphere entirely.  This refers back to both Levi-Strauss and Sapir's points that the human tendency to group according to binaries is both natural and yet also incapable of encompassing the vast spectrum of values held by a given society. The collective consciousness of national-level politics which, in America, values the Democrat versus Republican comparison, minimizes the spectrum of social viewpoints into a binary comparison first of parties (through the primary) and then of candidates (in a general election).  In accordance with Sapir's work, this creates a social behavior disjoint from the individual views of a group's members.

  Consider, for example, the 2020 Presidential election.  The debate in many circles was not about Biden's objective qualifications -- rather, the conversation was one of his subjective qualifications relative to the incumbent President. Similarly, a party that held a great deal of collective disdain for Harris at the primary level rallied around her as the VP nominee.  On November 3rd and the following days, news sources tracked the percentage of women who voted for each candidate, the number of racial minorities that voted for each candidate, the urban-rural divide for voter turnout, and a number of other binarisms. Statistics such as "57% of women and 45% of men voted for Biden" were common. If one were a member of a certain gender, a certain race, a certain sexual identity, or a certain religious sect and voted against the common position of their "group", then they were seen as an anomaly or, with a more negative connotation, were viewed as a traitor to their group. 

  The more deeply one looks into the political phenomena of the American system, the more clear it becomes that Democrats and Republicans may not be as different as they seem and that membership in the parties is far more diverse than stereotypes would lead us to believe.  As a collective society, we very rarely consider the complexity of the political system to which we subscribe or the intricacies of the legal-political system that defines and sanctions our norms and broader culture.  Counteracting our subconscious tendency to view Republicans and Democrats as being in direct opposition is the reality that not every member of a given party will subscribe to that party's national policy agenda. A New Jersey Republican and a Texas Democrat may blur the partisan lines in an effort to appeal to their regional constituencies, and two Democrat Representatives from New York and Ohio may vary a great deal in their policy views.  This is reflected more tangibly in the reality that a significant portion of federal legislation is passed with bipartisan support, or at the very least with a handful of Congresspeople crossing party lines (consider Mitt Romney).  

  This is not to say that there is no real difference between the American political parties; certainly, there are a number of deeply impactful social, legal, and cultural issues which are clearly influenced by the legislative and executive work of elected officials.  This influence surely differs based upon the political party in power at a given time.  However, politics is not a binary.  Racial, religious, socio-economic, and gender groups are not predestined to support one party and reject another.  There are not rigidly defined policies that are perfectly "Republican" or perfectly "Democrat".  Yet, these intricacies operate largely below the surface of consciousness -- impacting the way the collective consciousness of a given culture is formed, but rarely being considered in all of its complexity. This demonstrates, in my perspective, Sapir's conceptualization of the cultural organism or "social behavior" which operates with a great deal of unconscious complexity.  Likewise, it demonstrates Levi-Strauss and Sapir's shared perspective that cultural phenomena exist in degrees, but that they are oftentimes classified into binaries which seems to be natural but are actually simplified reflections of cultural norms and values. 


Comments

  1. Hey Ali, you put into words what i've been thinking for a while now, really great post! With your background in political science, I'm sure you have all sorts of ideas about the two-party system in America, and I agree with the ones you presented. I have felt that to the average American, choosing a political party affiliation is like picking a sports team, but there are only two teams. People pick their favorite sports teams for a multitude of reasons. Most do so because of who their parents tell them to root for. In American politics, we are shaped by what ideals our parents teach us from a young age that leads us to choose to vote a certain way when we turn 18. A close friend of mine was told by his father growing up that "real men are conservative" and struggled to find his own political identity his whole life. People also pick sports teams based on their location or birthplace. Similarly, my friend from rural Georgia was taught to think a certain way about ethnicity, the confederate flag, and other ideas typical of what you'd expect from rural Georgia. Her culture taught her to think a certain way, and she shaped her political affiliation based on the way people thought in her birthplace. People will also swear by their team even if they are clearly losing, and sometimes riot based on the outcome of a game. Politics should not be this simple, but culturally, it is as easy as rooting for the Yankees vs. the Red Sox.

    All of this analogy is just to say, I agree that politics is not a binary, and the people who view it this way don't necessarily care about the actual policies, just that their party holds the power and the rival party does not.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts