Social-Cultural Critique of Community Gardens

Food deserts, regions with limited access to affordable and nutritional foods, are a pervasive element of the United States. These are extremely problematic for low-income populations, and often leave people with no choice other than to eat fast food on a regular basis. This is detrimental to the populations health and it is an issue that is found across the country. One of the ways this problem is being combatted is through community gardens. These are public spaces where people in the community can go and grow produce, providing them with healthier and more affordable sources of food. This system of addressing basic human biological needs offers an excellent opportunity to study and apply Malinowski’s theory of functionalism.

Malinowski believed that human beings had seven basic needs: nutrition, reproduction, bodily comforts, safety, relaxation, movement, and growth. In his functionalist framework, people satisfy these basic needs with basic responses, and from those basic responses arise new “instrumental” needs, which are then solved with “instrumental” responses. People in food deserts often face a lack of nutrition, and to satisfy this basic need they construct community gardens. This is where a few different needs begin to arise. A large number of community gardens are constructed in urban areas, due to a lack of available land, only a limited number of gardens can be planted therefore, they have to be communal. Because these limited spaces are used by multiple people in order to meet their nutritional needs, there has to be a social organization created in order to regulate the interaction between the people that are gardening. This organization would regulate things like what can be planted in the garden, when people can work in the garden, the division of labor among gardeners, and how the produce is distributed among the gardeners. According to Malinowski, the resolution of this instrumental need then results in cultural needs. For the people working in the garden, the need to belong would likely result in the creation of other events surrounding the garden. This could be something as informal as a community gathering for a meal or go as far as establishing a farmer’s market where the gardeners could sell their produce to a larger audience.

It can also be argued that the other functionalist aspect of community gardening is gift giving, or reciprocity. Malinowski discusses this concept in-depth in his study of the Trobriand islands’ practice of the Kula. Essentially, once a gift is given there is an understanding that a gift of equal or greater value will be returned. This act of reciprocity is more likely to occur if the garden contains individual plots where people grow their own produce, as opposed to a fully communal garden. In this type of community garden people will offer their assistance or labor for a certain project. If a gardener helps another with planting, caring for crops, or harvesting, there is the expectation that the other gardener will return the favor. There is also the possibility that an in-group garden market might be constructed so that people within the community garden can trade their produce with one another. As with the fulfillment of the other basic needs that Malinowski describes, the natural human activity of reciprocity is followed by the creation of relevant instrumental structures. This structure could be as simple as a timeslot system where gardeners could sign up for alternating days to take care of each other’s plots, or the creation of other community events surrounding the in-group market. As with the totally communal system, the instrumental structure would create cultural needs such as the need to belong, and with the individual plot system, the need for prestige. If each gardener has their own plot, a structure of friendly competition may arise so that everyone can show off their skills as a gardener.

- Josh Milon

Comments

Popular Posts