Social-Cultural Critique: The internet’s impact on the formation of sub-generational groups
BY COLE NIKAS
Ruth Benedict, one of Boas’s most important students, has a key phrase that defines a large portion of her work. When I think of Benedict, I think “culture is personality writ large.” If Ruth Benedict were alive today, she would be made very secure in this assertion. The generational system we live in today has grown to be a complex web of commonly known and repeated stereotypes, traits, sayings, jokes, phrases, tendencies, and words. The introduction of the internet has allowed for this divergence, creating a more specific idea of generations, and thus creating micro-generations that share traits and identities.
The introduction of the internet was one of the most important technological advancements in human history. Anyone with a computer and connection can now have access to the sum of the world’s knowledge and can connect with others all across the globe. It has created a second reality of sorts, where we exist in our material life, but communicate and share information online. The complex relationship between the internet and the material world has had an unimaginable cultural impact, because with the billions of new connections we make online come new identities, groups, and shared ideals. Social media in particular has led to the idea of what I will be calling “sub-generations.” The invention of social media has expanded our access to influence, and has coined the term “influencer.”
Influencers on platforms such as Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, and YouTube are creators who had cultivated mass amounts of (typically young) followers who respect and look up to them, or at the very least are entertained by them. In this sense, Benedict is correct in saying that culture is personality writ large. People choose who they support online based on their personality, and sometimes it works in reverse. When we find an influencer we like based on compatibility with our personality, we join a community that has its own phrases, likes, dislikes, inside jokes, etc. This essentially creates an online community, and these communities just keep growing until the entire generation is talking about the influencers they like and are in on the joke. The jokes or phrases introduced to the audience become a generational staple for younger generations because we all saw it and appreciated it at some point. Today, Generation Z has its own entire set of vocabulary. Twitter and TikTok primarily feature the creators who start a new trend, like repeating a meme we’ve all seen or even buying a product to fit in, and it slowly cements itself as something everybody does. Since Gen Z populates the majority of TikTok, they have their own exclusive group that ends up including other Gen Z kids from around the world. More and more sub-groups appear within this generation, and comment section debates run wild with speculations about when generational cutoff points are. We even try to relate only to people with our same graduation year. This creation of these sub-generations is only seen in generations that grew up with the internet, Gen Z and Millennials.
With the formation of new cultures of young people that are labeled as generational, we are reminded that culture functions the same way our personalities do. We all join groups based on similarities in personality, so we adopt one collective identity and personality, and this can be applied on a generational scale. The internet has proved Ruth Benedict right because it makes it far easier to make observations about the way new cultures function in our modern plugged-in society. By applying Benedict’s theory, we understand more about internet phenomena such as influencers, relatability, and the creation of sub-generational groups of like-minded people that follow.
Cole, I found your social-cultural critique super interesting and very relevant to social media’s growing presence in our lives. I was particularly interested in your discussion of how different sub-groups form in relation to social media and social media influencers. In the past younger generations who were not accustomed to social media often sparked conversations with talk of different things going on in their lives such as different newspaper articles or how their family was doing, we can see a shift from one generation to the next, and social media plays a huge role in that. In our parents’ generation for example one of the first big social media platforms, Facebook was a way for older generations to keep up with one another from high school or college groups and could then spark discussions of experiences allowing for these groups to reminisce on old times and relationships. However, now we can see Gen Z populations, like you mentioned using memes or Tik Tok dances and trends to start conversations. An example of this is in the past year over quarantine when a new Tik Tok dance would start you would see a rush of influencers looking to be the first to be seen doing this new dance and completing it to perfection. This is then often used as a starting point for different relationships and conversations as they shifted from in-person experiences to now experiences strictly from participating in the following if different influences and have created groups based on which influencers people follow and look up to. While this often creates feelings of inclusion as these groups are created, it leaves those who do not share these followings or do not keep up with these trends out of the loop, leading to exclusivity. So, personally, I’m not sure if this shift is a good or bad thing, but one thing I do know is that these sub-groups do exist and it marks a large shift in relationship building and how our generation interacts with one another.
ReplyDeleteReally interesting application of Benedict's notion of culture as personality write large! Because social media facilitates at-a-distance communication, it is easy to overlook social platforms as cultural mediums when in fact they very much are. I definitely see how different social media outlets appeal to particular personalities -- and generations. Based on my experience, Facebook appeals more towards middle aged audiences who like to share photo albums and tips and tricks with family and friends, while a platform like TikTok appeals more toward Gen-Z. TikTok is an especially intriguing platform insofar as its recent popularity and growing user demographic. It seems that as time goes on, more generations are joining or at least partaking in filming the TikTok video clips (i.e. Gordan Ramsay & his daughters). This in mind, the app is centered around making videos that showcase dancing, humor, cooking etc. Hence, it seems less likely to see a middle aged person actively filming these clips and using TikTok. Thinking about TikTok humor, many TikTok references and jokes are derived from meme culture, slang and other pop culture trends that circulate among younger people. In turn, content seems as though it would not understood without necessary context.
ReplyDeleteAs you imply in your piece, algorithms that match a user with other users that share similar interests create a sort of "micro-culture." In this microculture, populations share “in-group” jokes, tips, and dance routines that would not be completely understood by an outsider. Hence, I argue that you could even take your application of Benedict’s ideas a step further. While you can link certain personality traits or general personalities to particular generations and applications, you can also link personality traits or general personalities to these algorithm-based microcultures. Returning to the TikTok example, there are various communities on TikTok that appeal to different kinds of users. Some communities that I can distinguish are the following: (1) the dance community, which appeals to teenage girls who want to appear attractive to gain a following and (2) the beauty community, which appeals to creative types who seek insider makeup tips. In both contexts, content creators strive to appeal to the interests of their followers and in turn, express themselves in a manner that offers insight into the traits or skills their respective “community” perceives to be valuable.