Social-Cultural Critique about Racism on Marx's Theory
By Hex Li
Marx’s German Ideology actually inspired me a new insight to understand the function of racism in the prevention of communism. Therefore, this blog can be either a reading critique or social-cultural critiques. Before I dive in, let me quickly remind you Marx’s standpoint and what was conveyed in German Ideology.
Being a materialist, Marx acknowledged Hegalian’s approach of which the society developed through stages, but he critiqued both Old Hegelian and Young Hegelian, as they believed that ideas and deity were the driving force of human development, whereas Marx and Engels believed that society grew upon the material condition and history was driven by conflicts between producers and exploiters. The origins of this conflict came from the means of production which resulted in division of labor. As production grew along the division of labor being more specialized, the development for Marx signaled five different forms and stages of ownership: tribalism, ancient communal and State ownership, feudalism, capitalism, and finally reached communism.
(Since we are mainly discussing capitalism and communism, I would skip the previous three stages and jump to the two.) In terms of labor in capitalism, the working class sells its labor for earning wages and the inequality happens between the value created by the working class and the wages was called surplus value, and this extraction of profit gradually formed an exploitation system. One of the reasons why that the working class, aka the proletariat, was manipulated was that the social aspect of the working class’s labor was objectified to the extent that their labor was dehumanized and the oppression from the ruling class was justified; as a result, this feishism towards commodity concealed the exploitation. Therefore, commodity fetishism became the biggest obstacle for the working class to fight against the ruling class. Meanwhile, Marx emphasized that, not only the proletariats were taken advantage financially and physically by having ownership on production, they were also subconsciously constrained mentally; the ruling class ideology occupies mainstream ideology in every era, since they are creating ideology to reinforce their dominant status.
However, Marx was opposimistic, as he predicted that the working class would eventually overcome the system and start to reform towards the direction of communism, in two prerequisites: firstly, wealth are controlled by a few people in the world and most of the people living almost have nothing, which, in this case, it would maximize the conflict between the two classes and allow reformation to happen; secondly, the growth of production is essential, as it would prevent extreme poverty that lead to a entire powerlessness state of the working class and the intercourse from production between people would stimulate all the prolitates in all regions to fight. Ultimately, capitalism would collapse and communism would be the dominant power.
But how come that nowadays the US didn’t become communist society? Similar with most of the earlier thinkers, one of the critiques that Marx encountered was the lack of cultural relativism which could result in distortion of reality. Emphasizing on the economic and material level of class conflict, Marx ignored the racial conflict that existed long ago. Since the beginning to middle of the 19th century German was under a social unrest with revolutionary economic growth, I can’t blame Marx for his materialism approach, but racial issues, no matter in German or the US have been a serious issue that are worth noting.
I argue that one of the reasons that communism hasn’t been achieved in the US is because of the growing of racism and white superiority, as racism has served as a defensive weapon towards Marx’s theory on the rising of communism--by further distinguishing race, the white bourgeois class creates inner conflict within the working class and establishes common enemy within race. As mentioned above, capitalism has been in need of a exploited system; as a result, after the colonialism and Atlantic Trade, the White bourgersis invaded the African American world and introduced them as a more inferior being to the white working class for the working class’s sense of safety, in order to exploit the White working class, Racism, in America, then has served as a tool for the white confidence and prevention of class alienation, which also became a justification towards inequality even beyond race. Being oppressed by the white bourgeois class as well, the white working class now can console themselves by thinking about the lower status of the African American, but forget the fact that both the African American and the white working class have the same enemy.
In reality, there is a clear trend that racism is still used as capitalism’s weapon in a global content. While globalization became an unavoidable trend under the need of capitalism according to Marx, it encountered more enemies as well, such as the rising of Asia. Thus, Asian hate and propaganda against communism, especially during the Vietnam War, started to be accelerated by racism, one of the most powerful weapons of capitalism. Furthermore, I argue that the popularization of far-right ideology and the associated racist crimes, for example the recent Atlanta shooting, nowadays are also the side-product of long-existed capitalism fighting against the rising of communism. And it’s more terrifying when the racism is deep rooted within the working middle class; the sheriff that is responsible for the Atlanta shooting case defended the victim in front of the world media by saying that “he just had a bad day.” and tweeted the link and encouraged people to purchase the clothes that have the slogan of “China Virus” during the global pandemic. The working middle class originally should be one of the most effective factors in the down-to-up approach to fight against racism and exploitation of capitalism, as some of them are involved in institution--such as local police station and local courtroom--which occupy the rational legitimate domination and have adequate social status which enable them to support the working class; but along the manipulation of racism that the white bourgeois employed towards the white working class, alienation between the working class would never happen.
Hey Hex! You do a great job in this post summarizing how Marx’s theories work in today’s society and tying them into theories of race and racism. Your post reminded me of a theory I was studying in another of my classes, sociology, and how Marx's view on capitalism and his conflict perspective have produced some interesting thoughts on racism in our modern western societies. The theory of the conflict perspective is that humans naturally divide themselves into social groups which then compete for resources (material or cultural) against other social groups. Groups which become more dominant and have more resources subjugate others, resulting in a power imbalance and the widespread mistreatment of those groups. Marx used this conflict perspective to discuss social and economic classes, but it applies to races as well.
ReplyDeleteAs you said, capitalism needs an exploited class, and to subjugate other people by defining them as a separate and lower race would fulfill that need - and satisfies the conflict perspective. I also thought you did a good job summarizing how politicians and groups in power divide people this way to keep themselves in power and the true dominant social force in today’s society. The current use of race as a weapon to divide people has reached to the highest echelons of our society, with the (recently) former president of the United States on record saying people from Mexico are “bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists” on the topic of immigration. By using race, ethnicity, and nationality as a way to divide people, politicians can gather a loyal base which believes the politician is ‘for them’, when in reality the politician is using them to gain or keep power.
Word Count: 283
A really first-rate discussion, thank you both. Check out Heather McGee's The Sum of Us for a fascinating account of what happened to public policy in the U.S. in the 20th century. She makes a similar argument! https://www.amazon.com/Sum-Us-Everyone-Prosper-Together/dp/0525509569
ReplyDelete