Response to Ruohan's Critique in White
By Hex Li
Hi Ruohan, I really love your critique over White’s article!
One thing you really inspired me is that the difference of focus between White and Steward when I read your line “White discusses that culture developed as humans extend control over the surrounding environment to increase food production…”. It seems to me that, while White emphasized on the dominance of Human beings and their capability of benefiting from the surrounding environment to develop their culture, Steward’s evolutionary theory, cultural ecology put more focus on the “adaptation” of human beings’ culture/social system based on the changes of environment, as human beings are positioned in a more passive spot in nature. For example, in Steward’s Patrilineal Band, he mentioned that, since the habitat of the small bands required them to hunt for living, male had taken more dominant position within the society; and, since all members of the band are patrilineally related, exogamy became a required form of marriage, whereas in White’s opinion, as you mentioned Ruohan, “the purpose of culture is to serve the needs of men…”including “those that can be satisfied by drawing resources within the human organism...and those that can be satisfied by extracting resources from the external world.” As a result, although both of the theorists’ beliefs are based on materialism, there is a clear distinction between their understanding of the relationship of culture and environment. In addition, for White, the progress of culture is a development and evolution of human beings, while, for Steward, the changing in culture is just an adaptation of the environment without a cultural hierarchy. Thus, both taking a more Marxian approach to materialism, Steward’s approach for me is more Bosian, as it requires us to analyze change in culture and social structure within its own environmental influence.
Comments
Post a Comment