Response to Mitch's "Critique of 'Introduction to Coming of Age in Samoa'"
BY JARRETT HALL
Mitch, I think you did a really great job at covering the significance of Margaret Mead and her ethnographic work with young women in Samoa. Building upon your argument, I completely agree that Mead's contributions to anthropology through historical particularism and her comparativist approach are essential buildings blocks for modern anthropology. I feel as though this was a vital aspect of her ethnographic fieldwork because it contradicted traditional ethnocentric, evolutionist frameworks; where all cultures and societies progress through the same stages of human development. Subsequently, she also opposed cultural universals and instead stressed the relation between personality and culture in her research.
I also think your analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of Mead is very effective. I would expand upon this by saying that despite her very in-depth ethnographic fieldwork, one particular statement she made within Introduction to Coming of Age in Samoa could be viewed as very troubling. Within her essay, she claimed, "because one girl's life was so much like another's, in an uncomplex, uniform culture like Samoa, I feel justified in generalising although I studied only fifty girls in three small neighboring villages" (p. 174-175). This builds upon your criticism of Mead for only working with a small portion of informants within her research. However, overall, I think that Mead's contributions to anthropology through her comparativist, anti-evolutionary concepts helped blaze a path for modern anthropologists and is why she is still so highly regarded to this day.
Comments
Post a Comment